News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by Cshelton on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:21PM (#16886643)
The lower speed on 4G is mostly due to the number of devices on it.

5G will be no different in that way. At first, the few people with 5G devices and networks will have very fast speeds (mostly), but once everyone in 4G moves to 5G, we’re back to how it is today.

I’m also curious what the effect of all the WiFi networks will have in regards to interference with 5G bands.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by jdietrich on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:29PM (#16887289)
The point of the article isn't that 5G won't improve throughput, but that improvements of the existing LTE network will provide similar improvements.

This is really a corporate squabblefest over branding, control of standards and intellectual property. There are misaligned incentives between IP holders like Qualcomm, equipment manufacturers and network operators.

The networks want the 5G brand so they can sell the image of an "all-new superfast network", but they want to spend as little as possible on new infrastructure. IP holders want to ensure that any future development is tied to licensing their technology. Equipment manufacturers want to sidestep those license costs, either by avoiding new technologies with freshly-minted patents or by moving to technologies with fewer dependencies on proprietary IP. US cable operators want access to millimetre bands to expand their fixed broadband network, while European landline broadband operators don't want new competition.

Nobody is being honest about those clashing incentives, so we're seeing huge amounts of babble and FUD from all sides.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by petra on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:34PM (#16887343)
So what do you think will be the end result of 5G ? same as William Webb says, that most likely, nothing will come out of it - because consumers are happy with current speed, and they're only interest is paying less, which doesn't fit with investing billions in 5G ?
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by antnisp on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:57PM (#16888018)
European landline operators ARE the networks.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by taeric on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:37PM (#16886780)
This doesn't seem to contradict the point. There is a fixed capacity that the network can handle. For 5G, this appears to be a higher capacity than for 4G.

So, yes, more devices will mean less speed for everyone. However, there is more speed to go around, so the same number of devices in a 4G setting will get less speed than the same number in a 5G.

Or is that not the GP's point?

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by okmokmz on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:39PM (#16886800)
>The lower speed on 4G is mostly due to the number of devices on it.

Is that the sole reason 5G is faster, or will being able to allocate less in idle situations and utilize spatial multiplexing support faster speeds even with a comparable number of devices?

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by taeric on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:46PM (#16886867)
Allocating less in idle situations sounds dangerous. What do you do when there is a real world event and everyone rushes to their device, pulling them out of idle?

(I'm assuming this problem is already considered. Genuinely asking, in case someone has a good link to read on it.)

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by jdietrich on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:05PM (#16887041)
It's straightforward QoS management. Public service users get absolute priority, even if that means kicking everyone else off the network. After that, voice and SMS get priority, because they're important to users and have very low data rates. IP traffic can have whatever's left on a fair queuing basis. Most operators use deep packet inspection and can perform fairly sophisticated traffic shaping.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by taeric on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:30PM (#16887302)
That makes some sense. But "kicking people off" is a crappy answer. Especially since you are setting up a constant storm of users trying to reconnect. Easy to see how that will not play well with idle connections.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by jdietrich on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:13PM (#16887674)
>Especially since you are setting up a constant storm of users trying to reconnect.

The network isn't that dumb. The technical details are far beyond the scope of a HN comment, but the network can gracefully deny service to users. Think about what happens if you run out of data allowance or prepaid credit - your phone doesn't frantically spam the network, it just asks for service and is politely told to try again later. If all else fails, you can just de-register all the devices connected to a given cell site and revert them to emergency calls only.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by taeric on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:49PM (#16887957)
Right, that was why I was asking if someone had a good link to read on. :)

And, honestly, from the way I've seen phones behave on older wifi networks, I would be surprised if some aren't actually spamming the network. Unnecessarily fast. Worse, I would hope the network has some protection built in for the bad actors that do.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by Rjevski on Saturday April 21, 2018 @05:03AM (#16890623)
> the network has some protection built in for the bad actors that do.

They don't. It's extremely easy to DoS an off-the-shelf (Ericsson, etc) mobile network if you know what to do. All it takes is one packet per minute or so. ;)

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by vinylkey on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:36PM (#16886772)
> but once everyone in 4G moves to 5G, we’re back to how it is today.

Would there be a benefit to split 50:50 between 4G and 5G?

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by phinnaeus on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:59PM (#16886993)
Couldn't we just increase 4G capacity in that case?
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by macintux on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:57PM (#16887539)
I would imagine there are fundamental limitations on the available bandwidth that splitting the traffic across multiple frequencies would alleviate...but that's just speculation.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by jburgess777 on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:38PM (#16889167)
LTE Advanced already supports a feature called carrier aggregation where your phone can transfer data on multiple different frequencies at the same time to boost its aggregate throughput:

http://www.3gpp.org/technologies/keywords-acronyms/101-carri...

Unfortunately that does not boost the overall capacity available so the higher peaks speeds may not improve the average experience.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by gruez on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:57PM (#16886967)
>once everyone in 4G moves to 5G, we’re back to how it is today.

is that why some budget MVNOs only offer 2g/3g access when their parent network has lte?