News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by notahacker on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:07AM (#16883802)
Whilst the apparent double counting doesn't seem fair, it also doesn't seem like a good idea for students who rely on government aid for their living costs to be speculating in risky exotic financial assets...
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by mcny on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:22AM (#16883850)
This is kind of off topic but we should really get rid of all income thresholds for government services and safety nets. They divide people and make them resent one another. I think we should instead make these programs available to all otherwise qualifying applicants (New York excelsior can keep the state residency requirement but should not be allowed to say it applies only to people who make under $125k a year).

If we "can't afford" to offer a program to all qualifying people regardless of income that means we don't have the political will to make the program happen and should get rid of it.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by brownbat on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:16AM (#16884114)
I sympathize with the consistency of a "pure universal" approach to policy, but like many purist policy philosophies, I don't think it would survive rigorous implementation.

For so many reasons. Chief among them, maybe, people are generally reluctant to support governments engaged in transfers of resources from themselves to billionaires.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by dictum on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:28AM (#16884190)
An instance of "ignorance is bliss": people would rather see transfers of resources from themselves to billionaires through corporate welfare (often advocating for it in hopes of a better local economy) and special interest lobbying than direct, documented and smaller cash transfers.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by yorwba on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:29AM (#16884195)
If you provide the billionaire with food stamps, but tax them at 10% of their net worth (which would reduce them to a mere millionaire in ≈65 years), I'm not sure whether anyone would complain about the food stamps.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by mcintyre1994 on Friday April 20, 2018 @10:21AM (#16884961)
Wouldn't the billionaire just leave and move somewhere that doesn't reduce their total worth every year?
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by marvin on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:33PM (#16886740)
This happens even in Norway, where the wealth tax is 0.85% of net worth per year. So you'd have to have some wealth tax everywhere the well-off would want to move.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by yunesj on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:02PM (#16885893)
I prefer the simpler policy, but strongly oppose the 10% net worth tax!

> I'm not sure whether anyone would complain

Maybe the billionaires would complain? Or is their sacrifice necessary for your greater good?

I would also complain. It's unethical. And, we don't need yet another tax on the most value-bearing (and typically philanthropic) people in society, to be collected by the most violent organization in history, to dole out food stamps and other benefits in the most inefficient way possible.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by annabellish on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:35PM (#16886236)
>we don't need yet another tax on the most value-bearing (and typically philanthropic) people in society

If we assume for a moment that this is true, then why would this state of affairs be okay? Society cannot run on the philanthopy of billionaires.

Further, there's not very much evidence that this is actually true. In terms of largest individual contributions, yes, many billionaires make impressive donations and pay for valuable things, but that's the all-too-common fallacy of looking at absolute figures when it's relative figures that matter.

Ignoring that a lot of charity and philantropic work wouldn't even be _necessary_ in a world with less extreme wealth inequality, the idea that non-billionaires aren't proportionally charitable doesn't really hold much water.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by yunesj on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:36PM (#16889346)
> Society cannot run on the philanthopy of billionaires.

Well, it doesn't run on taxes either. Successful societies runs on voluntary exchange.

Given how much of the taxes are paid by the ultra wealthy (most of them), how philanthropic they are (very), and how wasteful the government is (impressively), why would you assume that voluntary philanthropy cannot replace involuntary, state-managed welfare?

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by annabellish on Sunday April 22, 2018 @08:14AM (#16895848)
We have many historical examples of government-based systems working. We have many historical examples of individual-based systems not working.

Everybody just submitting to the hope that billionaires will take pity on them might even work with a sufficiently benevolent overlord, but you get the same problem as so many alternatives to democracy have: If you concentrate all the power in one person, or a small set of people, it's a breeding ground for corruption. Even if your set of people is entirely benevolent, over time as that set of people change it becomes near certain eventually you'll get people who aren't benevolent, and then everyone is fucked.

Democracy, and taxation-based systems of governmental funding, are less efficient than the best possible case elsewhere, but are primarily valuable for massively reducing the risk and dangers of bad actors. Concentrating power among an elite class has historically always been a fantastic way of increasing the risk and dangers of bad actors instead.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by jakelazaroff on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:25PM (#16887255)
> And, we don't need yet another tax on the most value-bearing (and typically philanthropic) people in society

Presuming you're talking about value-bearing in terms of job creation, this statement is tautological. In a society where a handful of people own the vast majority of the wealth, of course they're also the most value-bearing and philanthropic: they're the only ones who can be!

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by yorwba on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:34PM (#16886228)
See, you're not complaining about the food stamps.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by scott_s on Friday April 20, 2018 @10:27AM (#16885004)
Yes, they are. However, programs which do not require meeting any qualifications are massively easier to implement, which can make them much cheaper overall - think of all of the bureaucracy required for applying for and evaluating if various people meet the thresholds for programs, plus all of the appeals processes.

Then it becomes two questions: is the cost of enforcing the thresholds greater than the cost of just giving it to everyone, and can the public be made to understand this rational tradeoff.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by brownbat on Friday April 20, 2018 @10:14PM (#16889651)
> However, programs which do not require meeting any qualifications are massively easier to implement, which can make them much cheaper overall -

I agree you can get some efficiency gains from eliminating thresholds.

Back of the napkin, though, you're talking about an implementation cost delta (ie, only threshold determination costs) that swamps the benefit-and all other implementation costs-by several multiples, maybe an order of magnitude, depending on the size of the targeted group.

But ok... Although it's not my intuition that threshold costs would significantly outstrip the savings from targeting, it's just a factual question. For the sake of argument, say that happens in a case.

Then yeah, that's a great candidate for universality.

If those are the cases you want to focus on... Are we then agreeing that universality is preferable only in those cases where it pays for itself?

Because that is totally consistent with my position. If you only want universality when it's cheaper then we already agree and can just defer to the CBO.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by mcny on Saturday April 21, 2018 @06:21AM (#16890831)
> Because that is totally consistent with my position. If you only want universality when it's cheaper then we already agree and can just defer to the CBO.

No, I am not trying to argue it will be cheaper. It will likely be more expensive and/or worse for everyone involved but I think it will bring us all together. I think it is worth the extra cost or degraded service.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by whataretensors on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:07PM (#16885938)
It's also about helping young people who have parents who aren't filing taxes. I was poor and in this situation in college.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by mcny on Saturday April 21, 2018 @08:35AM (#16891201)
Yes. I know someone whose parents being very uncooperative is what made me think of this. My conspiracy theory is that politicians use these qualifiers to turn us into vote banks.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by notahacker on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:40AM (#16883937)
On the whole I think there's likely to be rather more resentment bred by cutting the subsidies of people that need them to ensure people that don't need them have equal access...
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by Jhsto on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:03AM (#16884050)
I understand where you are coming from, but let me add that this method of counting income applies to any investment income.

So say you put money into an index fund, but something unexpected happens. If you need to liquidate your savings while being a student, the government will slap your fingers for trying to think long-term.

Either way, I admit this only affects the poor -- if you are a bit better off you should be able to afford to incorporate an LLC for 2500€ (half a year rent where I live). By making yourself the sole owner of the company, you can get around all these problems, as juridically the LLC is a separate entity from you doing all the trading. This kind of setting is legal, but practically off limits for many.

Government aid for students is also practically unconditional in Finland and usually covers your rent and then some, basically making your own life instantly ramen profitable. This sounds utopistic to many, and it certainly is, but I think so much potential is lost by the government discouraging young people to take risks on their own.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by gamblor956 on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:42PM (#16886831)
So say you put money into an index fund, but something unexpected happens. If you need to liquidate your savings while being a student, the government will slap your fingers for trying to think long-term.

Not really much of a concern, as you would have to be wealthy enough to have spare money to put into an index fund while retaining enough liquid assets to cover your living expenses.

By making yourself the sole owner of the company, you can get around all these problems, as juridically the LLC is a separate entity from you doing all the trading. This kind of setting is legal, but practically off limits for many.

Not even remotely true. SMLLCs are disregarded entities for tax purposes, so their transactions are taxed directly to their owners. And legally, the concept of veil-piercing applies to SMLLCs generally, and especially to undercapitalized SMLLCs (meaning any LLC without sufficient independent assets to pay off all liabilities against it).

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by Jhsto on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:38PM (#16887373)
> Not even remotely true. SMLLCs are disregarded entities for tax purposes, so their transactions are taxed directly to their owners. And legally, the concept of veil-piercing applies to SMLLCs generally, and especially to undercapitalized SMLLCs (meaning any LLC without sufficient independent assets to pay off all liabilities against it).

This is true in Finland, which has fewer forms of corporations than the US for example. The corporation can decide to not pay out all of its earnings to its sole shareholder, but in such situation, the company needs to pay an additional 20% tax for the retained amount of money, for conducting a successful year of operations. This is rarely a good idea, but in this case where the owner is subject to constraints of personal income imposed by the government, it might make sense.