News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by ForHackernews on Friday April 20, 2018 @05:55AM (#16883496)
Having an immutable public ledger should make collecting taxes easier.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by DoctorOetker on Friday April 20, 2018 @04:52PM (#16888354)
I fully agree.

The whole idea of income tax is flawed.

Define richer (poorer) as having more (less) wealth: unit is say dollars.

Define net income as the time-derivative of wealth: unit is dollars per day.

Now conflate income and wealth in school. Justify taxing income as if it was redistribution from rich to poor, while it is in fact redistribution from high incomme to low income: i.e. a rich person with substantial capital, who has lost his job, can apply for income support, even though he still has money in the bank. In order to get out of poverty a poor person has to earn money at a faster rate than average, so will be heavier taxed.

Income taxation is not a redistribution from rich to poor, it is a means to slow down changes to the status quo. It is a brake on social mobility.

With decentralized ledgers, we can easily tax all wealth equally by printing money. The problem is not that money is being created out of thin air, but that this freshly minted money is not considered property of the group, instead it is property of the central banks, which act like unions for private banks.

Taxing by freshly minting is much cheaper to implement, and removes the whole legal loopholes with secret walkthroughs etc. i.e. people can focus on providing a service and earning money (roughly twice as fast since no income taxation) instead of puzzling through all the rules and exemptions in order to be able to do their job.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by wereHamster on Friday April 20, 2018 @06:06AM (#16883543)
…if you can match addresses to people.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by grey-area on Friday April 20, 2018 @06:17AM (#16883584)
Pretty trivial for a nation state, given sufficient motivation.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by StavrosK on Friday April 20, 2018 @06:20AM (#16883599)
Not if it's something like Monero.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by acdha on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:41AM (#16883942)
They can still require mandatory reporting when real money enters and leaves the system. Everyone is going to need to convert currency into Monero or vice versa and governments routinely require disclosure information at such points.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by StavrosK on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:11AM (#16884087)
Yes, for sure. But there can be a secondary market if people accept Monero directly, so you don't have to convert.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by acdha on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:23AM (#16884158)
Sure - just as cash and barter have allowed for millennia, but there’s an upper bound before that draws attention. Your landlord or supermarket have too much to lose if they help you cheat on your taxes.

With a digital transaction record keeping is less burdensome, too, so it’s more likely that if a substantial number of people started using cryptocurrencies the tax authorities would simply require reporting both sides of the transaction so they could confirm that the other party is reporting accurately as well.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:09PM (#16886557)
It always surprises me how casually crypto currency enthusiasts treat wilful money laundering and tax fraud.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by cfadvan on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:44PM (#16887929)
They’re almost as bad as the “sovereign citizen” crowd, more numerous, and just as sanctimonious. Maybe Blockchain has a future, but this current crop of money launderers and thieves don’t. Between the SEC in the US and tax authorities elsewhere, it’s a just a matter of time before having an immutable ledger of these activists is shown to be a really bad idea.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by StavrosK on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:19PM (#16886628)
The scenario you had in mind was money laundering and tax fraud? Mine was an oppressive government trying to dictate where you spend your money.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by acdha on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:42PM (#16887910)
Often with palpable enthusiasm, right before whining about the assumption that most non-speculative transactions are illegal.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by Sangermaine on Friday April 20, 2018 @11:13AM (#16885413)
This isn't a new problem for tax authorities, it's an old and solved one, despite the shiny new technological wrapper.

If you're making a lot of unreported income, there are ways for the tax authorities to know, in the same way they do with income from illegal activities that you're not reporting or large amounts of cash payments you're hiding, or just unreported income in general.

They don't need to match your identity to your Monero addresses. If you're using your Monero in any way that interacts with the real world they're going to ask where the money in your accounts came from, where the money for these assets you've been buying but don't seem to have a way to afford came from, where the money for these investments you've been making came from...

Even if you can somehow obtain things without converting out of the cryptocurrency, you're still acquiring assets, investments, and the like that require registration and disclosure, which will then lead to the same questions. Paying your monthly rent directly in cryptocurrency? If anyone audits or investigates you're going to have to explain how you're affording it when your reported income doesn't seem to support it.

And the sellers/landlords/etc will themselves have records, so you better hope they're also completely committed to protecting you if they themselves get audited or investigated.

Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by anonymfus on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:09AM (#16883804)
Good reason to ban Monero
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by VMG on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:19AM (#16883837)
Good reason to buy Monero
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by sametmax on Friday April 20, 2018 @06:36AM (#16883663)
zerocoin and private send is going to make that pretty hard.
Re:Finland tax authorities matching Bitcoin transactions and... by test6554 on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:10PM (#16887086)
...and if no assets are kept off the books