News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by dmfdmf on Thursday April 19, 2018 @10:16PM (#16881680)
The vast majority of people who have opinions on Ayn Rand or her philosophy of Objectivism haven't read a word of what she wrote and are repeating what they heard or have read it and failed to comprehend her ideas. Whether such failure is due to ability or dishonesty doesn't really matter.

Note the ad hom comments in this thread dismissing the content of this article because Binswanger inherited his money. Nobody has "deconstructed" Rand's ideas because they are true and because modern intellectuals are unable to rebut her arguments they are reduced to smears and gross misrepresentations of an important intellectual achievement.

My advice; read Rand's work firsthand and judge her ideas for yourself.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by BLKNSLVR on Saturday April 21, 2018 @05:18AM (#16890658)
"dismissing the content of this article because Binswanger inherited his money"

That fact should pretty much exclude Binswanger from having a public opinion on it because, whilst he may have worked hard for what he's got, the very fact of his being an 'heir' means his opinions will always be coloured by the likelihood of a life born into privilege.

Even if the ideas presented make sense in a highly-complex interwoven society, having articles written by someone potentially starting with heavy assistance will not help their cause. Get a genuine gutter-to-penthouse self-made person to write up how the common worker should be more thankful to their upper management and company-owners that they rarely see, much less have any interaction with. I'd read that with interest.

(Disclaimer: I've not read Rand, so I'm knowingly squarely within dmfdmf's crosshairs. I understand the basic concepts, but do need to actually read the source material - and am planning to do so, in order that I can "deconstruct" properly)

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by dmfdmf on Saturday April 21, 2018 @12:05PM (#16891939)
The truth or falsehood of the content is independent of Binswanger's income source and can be verified apart from that fact. This is the meaning of Ad Hominem fallacy, to get people to dismiss an argument not because it is false but because of some supposed flaw or fact about the person making the argument. Moreover, this is the exact method by which the Communists dismissed the objections to communism, accusing anyone who defended property rights as "bourgeois" and biased because they owned property. They established multiple brutal dictatorships last century that led to the death of millions and are still active today.

I truly hope you follow through with your intent, ignore the smears and misrepresentations, and read Rand firsthand and judge for yourself. As the first book I recommend Philosophy Who Needs It followed by The Virtue of Selfishness and leave the politics for later. Rand argued that politics follows from ethics and that is where the debate needs to shift if you want to understand the dire state of the world.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by Semirhage on Saturday April 21, 2018 @12:09PM (#16891951)
You opened with this: The vast majority of people who have opinions on Ayn Rand or her philosophy of Objectivism haven't read a word of what she wrote and are repeating what they heard or have read it and failed to comprehend her ideas.

That is ad hominem against a straw man, so I’m applying grains of salt heavily to your commitment to logical and rhetorical integrity.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by dmfdmf on Sunday April 22, 2018 @12:49PM (#16897009)
My logical and rhetorical integrity is intact, you don't really know what ad hominem means.

It means to raise some irrelevant fact about the person making the argument as a reason to dismiss what the person is claiming. E.g. don't listen to Binswanger because he is rich.

The vast majority of people who attack or dismiss or smear Ayn Rand have not (or superficially) read what she wrote but this is a fact that IS relevant to whether their opinion on Ayn Rand has any merit so its not ad hom.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by Semirhage on Sunday April 22, 2018 @05:26PM (#16898686)
Reassertion of your unsupported claim about who has and hasn’t read something still isn’t an argument, it’s stil a straw man. Do you have any substance to offer?
Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by dmfdmf on Sunday April 22, 2018 @06:59PM (#16899169)
Before we move on to your new Straw Man accusation, let's close out your old accusation that my argument is Ad Hom. Do you concede that point, if not why?
Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by Semirhage on Monday April 23, 2018 @12:58PM (#16905206)
There’s nothing new here.

That is ad hominem against a straw man, so I’m applying grains of salt heavily to your commitment to logical and rhetorical integrity.

Is the first thing I said. Meanwhile I stand by it, but it seemed prudent to break it down point by point until you had nowhere left to go. “All of these people I must invented haven’t even read the books!” Is still just what I said it was.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by dmfdmf on Monday April 23, 2018 @08:24PM (#16908756)
The implication of your position (i.e., that my argument is Ad Hom) is that the validity or merit of someone's opinion of Ayn Rand's work is independent of whether they have read her work or not is absurd on the face of it. It implies that people can have valid or valuable opinions on subjects of which they are completely ignorant. These implications are independent of whether my claim is true or false (which, I agree, is a disputable point or at least one that must be validated).

> Meanwhile I stand by it...

You can stand all you want but your position is not defensible in logic. I will repeat what I previously stated: You do not know what Ad Hom means. I know this for a fact because you fail to see an obvious implication of your position. We can address the validity of my claim but only if you see that my argument is not Ad Hom. If not then there is not much else to discuss.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by Semirhage on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @10:41AM (#16912947)
...are repeating what they heard or have read it and failed to comprehend her ideas.

Remember saying that? I’m getting tired of having to “remind” you of what has been said, so yes, we’re done.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by specialist on Thursday April 19, 2018 @10:45PM (#16881796)
That's true of every cult's membership.

It's a mistake to confuse proclaimations with beliefs. What sounds like gibberish to outsiders is just ways for members to find each other, validate their shared identity, reinforce their superiority.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by dmfdmf on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:02AM (#16882267)
Have you read Philosophy Who Needs It?, Have you read the Virtue of Selfishness? Have you read Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal? Have you read The New Left:The Anti-Industrial Revolution? Have you read The Voice of Reason? Have you read Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology?

Pick one and refute it instead of spreading the old and tired "cult" smear. You would be the first.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by specialist on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:19AM (#16884135)
Do Christians read the bible? Do randians read her works? Do capitalists read Adam Smith? Do Marxists read his Manifesto?

No.

And neither do their critics.

Settle down. I was supporting your point.

And yes, I was once in highschool, read my share of Ayn Rand. Then I grew up.

Re:It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1% by dmfdmf on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:01PM (#16885887)
You have plenty of company.