Re:Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
by zeveb on Friday April 20, 2018 @10:42AM
(#16885140)
One slight correction: I realised later on that in the current draft spec, unquoted tokens must not start with a digit. Thus the example would be:
(message
(previous (hash sha256 |XphMUkWQtomKjXQvFGfsGYpt69sgEY7Y4Vou9cEuJho=|))
(author (public-key (ed25519 |FCX/tsDLpubCPKKfIrw4gc+SQkHcaD17s7GI6i/ziWY=|)))
(sequence "216")
(timestamp "2018-04-19T17:53:26Z")
(content (type vote)
(link (hash sha256 |DlBH/hCmXfVzks2uY+WIll4aTzxrfBA8m/3GIdX3Vew=|))
(value "1")))
Re:Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
by dragonwriter on Friday April 20, 2018 @11:31AM
(#16885590)
Perhaps more to the point, the need for canonicalization in this use case is well understood from not only canonical S-expressions, but similar things done in XML and other cryptographically signed structured data formats. While not using one of the existing formats is not necessarily a bad thing, overlooking the well-established need for canonicalization is quite bad.
Re:Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
by Vendan on Thursday April 19, 2018 @05:31PM
(#16880336)
Agree completely. I don't know if I'd choose s-expr, but at the bare minimum, wrapping with signatures is the sane thing to do.
Re:Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
by vvanders on Thursday April 19, 2018 @11:03PM
(#16881881)
Yup, I've got an implementation of http over packet radio I've been working through and came to the same conclusion. Header contains the signature, base64 the message for verification.
Even though it's super low bitrate(1200bps/9600bps) since you have a binary foundation w/ base64 you can send raw binary to get low over-head but then easily verify+decode since base64 is well supported across a wide range of languages.
Re:Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
by walterbell on Thursday April 19, 2018 @05:59PM
(#16880544)
Which large scale open-source or commercial software is using s-expr today?
Re:Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
by bwbw223 on Thursday April 19, 2018 @07:49PM
(#16881148)
WebAssembly text format? https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/WebAssembly/Underst...
Re:Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
by _emacsomancer_ on Thursday April 19, 2018 @07:04PM
(#16880935)
Hacker News. Emacs. Anything Lispy.
Re:Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
by duncan_bayne on Thursday April 19, 2018 @06:28PM
(#16880731)
Why do you ask?
The SPKI version of a message would look something like (I've removed the hash property, because I don't think it makes sense for an object to specify the hash to be used to refer to it, but one could add it back in if one wished):
The transport version would be this (you can Base64-decode it to see the canonical version): And a signed message might look something like: Canonical S-expressions already buy you bit-for-bit identity when hashing, and SPKI (as an example) wraps signatures rather than injecting them — the only sane choice.Why do I bring this up? Obviously it's possible to make JSON be a cryptographically-sound format (either by foregoing objects for arrays, or by rules around object-field ordering, along with other rules about encoding), but using it instead of an already-sound format indicates an unfamiliarity with prior work in the field.