Re:Facebook to ask everyone to accept being tracked so they ...
by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 19, 2018 @01:16AM
(#16873493)
> but that particular measure is transparently aimed at undermining entire business models
Yes, but that's the entire point. That's why this regulation exists That's why it has so many fans here on HN.
Not sure if there's a qualitatively different way of achieving the same goal with a different method. There probably isn't, so it boils down to a careful balancing act - how to damage those business models without going overboard and having all US companies show EU the finger.
If the likes of Facebook and Google all turned off their services across the EU for a day, and replaced them with a SOPA-blackout-style message explaining that they can't afford to continue providing services without the ad model that pays for them, a lot of people would notice, and the EU probably wouldn't get nearly as easy a ride afterwards. I don't know how much damage would be caused if those same big tech firms cut off EU citizens permanently, but for better or worse, very many people now rely on the likes of Facebook and Google Mail for their everyday lives, and I'm betting the damage would be worse to the EU citizens than it would be to Facebook's and Google's financial statements (assuming the alternative is that they continue to operate but with a heavily damaged business model).