Re:The Dow of Cities
by rmah on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:44PM
(#16871000)
Why not just use the Case–Shiller index? It's been around for 18 years, has data from 1890 to today, has a solid methodology that has been scrutinized by many economists, and is the industry standard for US residential home prices. Oh, and it's also widely quoted in the financial media.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Dow of Cities
by twelvechairs on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:57PM
(#16871597)
Case-Shiller cuts it a different way though. The post is pointing out that city centre areas in general are increasing in value compared to outer areas. Case-Shiller is an index of price trends across different metro areas that doesnt differentiate city centres from suburban areas.
I don't think the headline statement for a 'dow of cities' is really useful to implement.
But there is a good point in there of society and industry not paying much attention to broad trends in cities. Case-Shiller is well regarded, but its a very blunt tool for analysis.
They're comparing zip-code level Case-Shiller index based on distance from city center. Metro level (which is what is widely quoted as far as I know) does not get at what they're trying to characterize, which is relative demand for housing in more urban environments.