News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Dropbox for source control by mechanical_fish on Monday September 13, 2010 @12:29PM (#1687083)
I think it's a poor idea.

A set of backup snapshots is not the same as source control. Your source control history is a story you tell about your code. Each commit is an important event, encapsulated on its own, with a person to blame and a text description and a definite date. Whereas a history of file changes is just a history of file changes.

The other point to make is that there is only one timeline of file changes. That is far too one-dimensional for code development. You need the ability to branch.

Using Dropbox for source control is like publishing an hour-by-hour activity log and claiming it's your autobiography:

  9 am: Typing. Still breathing.
  10am: Typing. Still breathing.
  11am: walking to lunch, breathing faster
  noon: eating.
  1pm: typing. Still breathing.
You want a system that tracks the deliberately edited, important points of the story. You also want backups, of course, but they don't accomplish the same thing.
Re:Ask HN: Dropbox for source control by justrudd on Monday September 13, 2010 @12:47PM (#1687146)
Also, Dropbox only keeps 30 days by default unless you pay for the Pack Rat option.