Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi...
by ucaetano on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:52PM
(#16871080)
> God in some form is indeed a simpler and more straightforward concept than evolution, especially when you consider the whole of evolutionary theory beyond Darwin. It's a very deep and complex subject.
Not really, because you don't actually have to describe evolution. It is a natural outcome of the most fundamental laws of physics.
You only need the fundamental laws of physics, everything else is a derivation from it.
Putting god into it means you need the same laws of physics, plus god, who also breaks the laws of physics. It doesn't simplify anything.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi...
by watwut on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:22PM
(#16870819)
Or maybe we should stop using the razor, because it us way too often wrong. I the absence of evidence, you don't know and eithe admit that or guess probabilities.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi...
by api on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:12PM
(#16871233)
"Razors" of this sort are only rules of thumb that tend to be right often enough to be useful. They are not laws of nature.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi...
by watwut on Thursday April 19, 2018 @03:02AM
(#16873910)
But here it was used as an argument - I am right because it is simpler explanation. Doing that is a fallacy and doing that after you personally phrased both theories so that the right one is simple is manipulation combined with fallacy.
The "Now use Occam's Razor." demand is wrong use of Occam's Razor. It is dishonest rhetoric that uses Occam's Razor as math theorem rather then rule of thumb.
God in some form is indeed a simpler and more straightforward concept than evolution, especially when you consider the whole of evolutionary theory beyond Darwin. It's a very deep and complex subject.
Ockham's razor is not "the simplest idea is true." It's "In the absence of evidence to the contrary, the simplest explanation is probably the correct one." Ockham's razor is probably related to thermodynamics since more complex explanations imply more complex structures. Extremely complex structures and thus explanations do exist, but they're less likely.
In the case of Tesla there's a lot of circumstantial evidence that they're currently the target of a massive negative PR campaign. I am not necessarily defending them if they have in fact treated employees badly, and both things could be true as I said elsewhere.