News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by ucaetano on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:54PM (#16870556)
Translation:

"Things in the universe happen for no greater reason at all, they just happen according to a small and simple set of laws that describe the behavior of matter-energy and space-time"

vs.

"There's a being, which is conscious, all-knowing and all-powerful, sitting somewhere, or actually nowhere, that uses its power to set things in motion or not, depending on its mood, and how it likes some people, but by no means follows a steady logic, and also isn't detectable by any means whatsoever and there is absolutely no evidence of its existence, but it exists and has impact on the universe, even if such impact can never be measured or even detected"

Now use Occam's Razor?

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by api on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:59PM (#16870608)
You've shown that it is possible to shorten or lengthen sentences by picking less or more applicable or "conceptually dense" words. Example: "the wall is black" vs "the wall absorbs a significant fraction of the visible light spectrum."

God in some form is indeed a simpler and more straightforward concept than evolution, especially when you consider the whole of evolutionary theory beyond Darwin. It's a very deep and complex subject.

Ockham's razor is not "the simplest idea is true." It's "In the absence of evidence to the contrary, the simplest explanation is probably the correct one." Ockham's razor is probably related to thermodynamics since more complex explanations imply more complex structures. Extremely complex structures and thus explanations do exist, but they're less likely.

In the case of Tesla there's a lot of circumstantial evidence that they're currently the target of a massive negative PR campaign. I am not necessarily defending them if they have in fact treated employees badly, and both things could be true as I said elsewhere.

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by ucaetano on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:52PM (#16871080)
> God in some form is indeed a simpler and more straightforward concept than evolution, especially when you consider the whole of evolutionary theory beyond Darwin. It's a very deep and complex subject.

Not really, because you don't actually have to describe evolution. It is a natural outcome of the most fundamental laws of physics.

You only need the fundamental laws of physics, everything else is a derivation from it.

Putting god into it means you need the same laws of physics, plus god, who also breaks the laws of physics. It doesn't simplify anything.

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by watwut on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:22PM (#16870819)
Or maybe we should stop using the razor, because it us way too often wrong. I the absence of evidence, you don't know and eithe admit that or guess probabilities.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by api on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:12PM (#16871233)
"Razors" of this sort are only rules of thumb that tend to be right often enough to be useful. They are not laws of nature.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by watwut on Thursday April 19, 2018 @03:02AM (#16873910)
But here it was used as an argument - I am right because it is simpler explanation. Doing that is a fallacy and doing that after you personally phrased both theories so that the right one is simple is manipulation combined with fallacy.

The "Now use Occam's Razor." demand is wrong use of Occam's Razor. It is dishonest rhetoric that uses Occam's Razor as math theorem rather then rule of thumb.

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by soheil on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:02PM (#16870635)
Using longer sentences and adding arbitrary words does not make an explanation more complex.

I was simply pointing out that simplest explanation may not always be the most accurate.

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by kps on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:18PM (#16870782)
> Using longer sentences and adding arbitrary words does not make an explanation more complex.

Exactly.

A creator-god does not explain the complexity of life, it just adds an additional layer, so the combined system is more complicated than the original. That's precisely what Occam's Razor rejects.

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by ucaetano on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:32PM (#16870908)
I'll rephrase again:

"A"

vs.

"A AND there's a being, which is conscious, all-knowing and all-powerful, sitting somewhere, or actually nowhere, that uses its power to set things in motion or not, depending on its mood, and how it likes some people, but by no means follows a steady logic, and also isn't detectable by any means whatsoever and there is absolutely no evidence of its existence, but it exists and has impact on the universe, even if such impact can never be measured or even detected"

Now use Occam's Razor?

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by afterburner on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:21PM (#16870812)
> Using longer sentences and adding arbitrary words does not make an explanation more complex.

You mean like what you did?

"There is God" doesn't explain anything. You're relying on the reader to already know what God is, and how God affects things.

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by rdiddly on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:11PM (#16870716)
You're in luck, Occam's Razor doesn't say anything about what's always accurate. It's more like advice, telling you to prefer the explanation that requires making the fewest assumptions.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by bildung on Thursday April 19, 2018 @04:11AM (#16874180)
Occam's Razor is about the need of additional assumptions to explain observed behaviour. Existance of a god is a pretty heavy assumption, ergo that explanation is not the simple one.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by jonny_eh on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:54PM (#16870550)
Are you trying to point out that Occam's Razor is flawed?

Occam's Razor would tell you that evolution (which has over a century of evidence) is more likely than a designer god (which is lacking in evidence).

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by watwut on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:24PM (#16870836)
God is simpler then original theory of evolution which is simple the current evolutionary theory.

Occam razor favors simplications over careful analysis.

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by bildung on Thursday April 19, 2018 @04:14AM (#16874192)
Occam's Razor is not about superficial simplicity but rather about the need of additional assumptions. God existing is a very big assumption, so that theory is the less simple one.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor

Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by notyourday on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:04PM (#16871177)
Actually it is reverse. Evolution is much simpler as a theory than an idea of God creating everything correctly
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by watwut on Thursday April 19, 2018 @02:47AM (#16873846)
By correctly you mean "in present state"?
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by notyourday on Thursday April 19, 2018 @09:22AM (#16875673)
Yes, as in the currently observable state because since there's no such thing as evolution, then from the beginning god would have had to create every single relationship that all living and non-living things had, have or will have.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by watwut on Thursday April 19, 2018 @09:43AM (#16875813)
Since God is assumed to be all powerful and all knowing, it would follow that he would have no problem to create the world "correctly".
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by notyourday on Thursday April 19, 2018 @03:49PM (#16879461)
And that's exactly where Occam's razor is a problem
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by watwut on Thursday April 19, 2018 @04:17PM (#16879712)
Yes, that is exactly what I am trying to say. You cant use Occam's razor to decide and demanding that other people instantly go with seeming easier solution is manipulative. It relies on people being unwilling to criticize or call Occam's razor use as bullshit - due it being repeated often.
Re:California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Condi... by rdiddly on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:05PM (#16870668)
Confusing example, since both statements are saying the same thing. "Exalting" the "higher" animals over the others is roughly equivalent to thinking there's a God. More precisely they both evidence the same fond desire, and intellectual bias, to impose a dreamed-up hierarchical structure on nature, rather than to describe nature itself. Presumably the first speaker wishes Man to be the God, whereas the second wants God to be the God. Occam's Razor is that they're both wrong and there's no hierarchy or God necessary.