Political destabilizing through the internet is a real thing and has been for many years and as more companies rely heavily on the internet for their business - stability of the internet infrastructure is very much tied to individual countries economic health and faith.
Does China go too far in regulating their internet? Most probably yes.
Is China's internet policy completely unreasonable on unfounded security grounds? Abso-fucking-lutely not.
The problem is no one really knows what the middle ground between the openness of the internet and policing it just the right amount. So we end up with an extreme case like China.
This argument would hold water if China's Internet policies were unique to telecom. They're not. The same instruments which protected Baidu and Tencent promote local steelmakers, phone makers, car manufacturers, battery and solar panel manufacturers and every other industry with a Princeling [1] attached.
> As much as its fashionable to hate on China and its government
Putting this at the end because it's a semantic comment. This is a silly way to attempt to dismiss a valid argument.
> it's a semantic comment.
Is this correct usage? I read that as "it's a meaningful comment" which seems opposite to the intended use.
For the most part the country is economically and socially stable and improving at rapid pace. Yes the country has its share of problems, but name me one country, democratic, developed or otherwise that doesnt have their share of problems.
The American/Western exceptionalism attitude towards other countries is kinda nauseatic.
China is not going around rigging pro-western government democratic countries election. Funding uprising and waging wars directly or directly (at least not at the scale USA is). Russia tried openning up their country and we know what happened to them, China may one day become more open but can't really blame them for being sceptical of the rest of the world.
So too is the "everyone's on aggregate just as bad as each other and everything is the same" equivocating approach to evaluating different countries and their systems.
>For the most part the country is economically and socially stable and improving at rapid pace. Yes the country has its share of problems, but name me one country, democratic, developed or otherwise that doesnt have their share of problems.
Nobody is saying Western countries are perfect. We just have the confidence in liberal democracy to at least say it is at least vastly superior to the dystopia China currently is. To say "China is improving at a rapid pace" is myopic. If you only care about economic development, then you are right, but if you care about civil liberties and human rights, then you could not be more wrong.
The difference between those and and the sites that are blocked (not just Facebook and Google, but also international newspapers) is that they cooperate with the Chinese government by censoring their websites, and the others do not.
Economically, Chinese social media isn't very relevant to the government. Since they are not exporting anything, protectionism in that sector doesn't really pay off. But being able to control what the populace can see and hear about the world is very important to them.
So the major reason for the internet blocks is security. It's the security of the state against its own citizens, but security nonetheless.
There is zero correlation between security and being blocked in China. There is a strong correlation between competing with politically-connected Chinese entities and getting blocked / being forced to surrender key IP. The backdoor argument is a red herring.