News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"If you are not paying for it..." by kiba on Monday September 13, 2010 @09:02AM (#1686376)
People still pay for development tools. Lots of people paid for IntelliJ IDEA even with Eclipse around.

I think a free product have to be utterly superior to a paid product in order to displace commercial products.

The cost of replication or the lack of substitutes is irrelevant ... people don't use GIMP over Photoshop because a Photoshop substitute is fucking hard to develop ... it took 22 years to reach its current state.

I am not parsing this statement. Do you mean that because it take 22 years to develop Photoshop, that it is impossible for GIMP to be good enough to be a substitute good thus eventually displacing it?

Re:"If you are not paying for it..." by pchristensen on Monday September 13, 2010 @11:47AM (#1686924)
"I think a free product have to be utterly superior to a paid product in order to displace commercial products."

In order to completely displace commercial products, yes. But for any reasonably complex or powerful product, there's a market of customers that are overserved by it and would pay less for less if they could. This is usually handled by product segmentation - think of options in cars. If you don't need the extra power, go for the 4-cylinder instead of the V-6. If cash is more important than comfort, skip the leather seats. If you need the fastest, most luxurious car and money isn't an option, check every box on the list.