Re:Ask HN: Do we need fully decentralized systems?
by vk23 on Monday April 16, 2018 @06:27AM
(#16847932)
I would argue that git at its core solves the problem of handling a shared verifiable state. The history of a git repository is build on the same hashing principles as a blockchain to ensure that history cannot be changed. The main difference to a blockchain is that in order to change the state you have to convince other humans that your change is valid.
In my understanding the main selling point of blockchains is to outsource the accepting of state changes to a consensus protocol which does not involve human interaction/interference. And just as git a blockchain still works if only one or few actors are involved.
Re:Ask HN: Do we need fully decentralized systems?
by fastdev on Monday April 16, 2018 @09:15AM
(#16848705)
> In my understanding the main selling point of blockchains is to outsource the accepting of state changes to a consensus protocol which does not involve human interaction/interference. And just as git a blockchain still works if only one or few actors are involved.
Agree. git works for vaguely defined rules like "is this README readable, up to date, and useful" where human input is necessary.
Blockchains can be used to enforce clearly defined rules like rules of a smart contract or rules of spending virtual money.
So roughly speaking: git = blockchain - distributed_consensus + fork_merges
I don't thing we disagree here. I am just pointing out that blockchain/Bitcoin/Ethereum is different because it allows to main a shared, verifiable state, something that BitTorrent, Git and Email do not provide. An ability to have this shared state is the main selling point of blockhain based systems.