Re:Ask HN: Do we need fully decentralized systems?
by andreasklinger on Monday April 16, 2018 @11:38AM
(#16849683)
Centralized marketplaces / price comparison services / middle men etc exist and do a good job
But very often they can't do the optimal prices or all the inventory - eg stock not listed on nasdaq - so it comes down to "are you able to move quickly/cheaply" (and/or is the inventory able to move quickly/cheaply)
Re:Ask HN: Do we need fully decentralized systems?
by fastdev on Monday April 16, 2018 @12:01PM
(#16849933)
> But very often they can't do the optimal prices
Are there any reasons why a centralized marketplace are worth in price discovery?
> eg stock not listed on nasdaq
I guess if a stock is not listed on Nasdaq it either listed somewhere else or there are some (probably reasonable) legal restrictions that prevent it from being listed.
It seems that we already have similar marketplaces implemented in a centralized fashion, e.g., Nasdaq. It allows to perform price discovery and does not force you to see to a specific party.
Do we really need to build a decentralized marketplace?