News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by goatherders on Saturday April 14, 2018 @05:56PM (#16839770)
There have been apps in the past that limit friends. I've thought a bout a 2 person network for you and your partner as well as one with maybe 20 friends. As well as one where you only see updates from friends who include you in their 20 as well. But it breaks the financial model of running targeted ads so it wont work.
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by textmode on Saturday April 14, 2018 @06:28PM (#16839919)
"But it breaks the financial model of running targeted ads so it won't work."

By "it", do you mean the software won't work?

What if someone wrote the software to do this, it worked and he distributed it for free?

To the entrepreneur, this perhaps is not interesting.

Is it interesting to the user?

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by goatherders on Saturday April 14, 2018 @07:03PM (#16840073)
I mean that targeting ads comes from harvesting lots of info. If the only thing the data shows is a single relationship then it is an order of magnitude lesser than if you are pulling data from hundreds of relationships.
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by textmode on Saturday April 14, 2018 @07:44PM (#16840229)
Could this property be of interest to the user that wants communications free from advertising, e.g., if she understands that the "social network" architecture created by the users of the software is such that there is no incentive for ads.

For example, if the software allows users to create many small groups all communicating separately, peer-to-peer, not aggregated into the same "network" via an enormous third party website.

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by collyw on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:54AM (#16842145)
The beauty of capitalism. You only get the stuff built that makes someone money, not the stuff that is genuinely useful. (Obviously there will be some overlap, but "most useful to the consumer" isn't always going to line up with "makes most money for the company").
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by textmode on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:48AM (#16843142)
What if the "stuff" already exists? What if economics had no bearing on its creation?
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by aggie on Saturday April 14, 2018 @06:08PM (#16839820)
Seems like targeting small groups could be a way to overcome the network effect of Facebook. Just convince a handful of friends to join. Maybe a free trial or freemium model would work?
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by firasd on Saturday April 14, 2018 @06:38PM (#16839967)
I've thought a WhatsApp equivalent for just families or even for specific events (like a wedding) would be cool. In addition to the regular chat window, there would be shared photos and so on.

But I think the challenge is not the financial model, the problem is product/market fit. Path (founded by a former FB exec) tried for a few years to create an intimate social network but couldn't retain enough users to make the biz work.

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by adventured on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:31AM (#16842099)
Path may have been a case of timing. They arrived right during peak Facebook buzzsaw growth, where Facebook was taking over. They stepped in front of that. It would be interesting to see how it - or something equivalent - would fair were it starting out today.

I'm increasingly of the opinion that there is no future market for an all-encompassing social network. That Facebook will stick around perpetually, like a moss. It's primary purpose will be to act as that one giant connection point with three billion users. The future growth markets are in the specialized segments that splinter off, of which there will be hundreds. They'll be targeted social networks, that do specific things dramatically better than Facebook ever can (and things that FB will never bother with). The early examples are well known: LinkedIn, Reddit, HN, Instagram, Twitter, WhatsApp, Snapchat, Stack Exchange, Genius, Yelp. Over time there will be one for everything imaginable that has at least a modest audience.

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by dindumuffin on Saturday April 14, 2018 @10:29PM (#16840785)
Path, Peach, Vero, Ello, I don't think we need another one to remind everybody that "intimate social networks" are a failed experiment. If someone wants to communicate within a small group, they are inclined to use group chat. Forget monetizing, first it's difficult to get users to stay on these platforms because:

1. Even if you get amazing press and hype, the churn rate can exceed your growth rate due to how limited the network effect is e.g. Peach and Vero.

2. People can already choose to unfollow celebrities and limit their friend groups on any existing social platform. It's simply a matter of willpower or creating an alternate account ala how "Finstagrams".

3. Celebrities and influencers are what drives growth to a platform. Donald brought Twitter tens of millions of new users. Hundreds of millions of guys use Instagram just to follow bikini models etc

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by qznc on Sunday April 15, 2018 @03:05AM (#16841632)
There is no need to start as a social app. You could start as a to-do app. For example, if Todoist would add a persistent group chat to shared lists, it might replace the WhatsApp conversations with my wife.

There are apps that are used in intimate settings. They can be made "social".

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by fwn on Sunday April 15, 2018 @03:50AM (#16841755)
I think it's very dangerous to add social to a non-social service.

Evernote tried adding a chat functionality they, for some reason, named "work chat".

No other Evernote user I know wasn't hostile towards this feature.

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by qznc on Sunday April 15, 2018 @08:02AM (#16842302)
It is not intuitive to me why that would be bad. Care to elaborate?
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by ReverseCold on Saturday April 14, 2018 @06:10PM (#16839828)
> 2 person network for you and your partner

Chat apps?

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by goatherders on Saturday April 14, 2018 @06:15PM (#16839847)
Yeah but would be cool to have an area to share "stories," text messages, video calls, grocery lists, etc. Maybe there is money in integration wherein if my partner likes a Chanel purse on FB or Pinterest the partner app let's me know so I can buy it dir her.
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by fwn on Sunday April 15, 2018 @03:56AM (#16841773)
But all of that already exists. A million chat apps that also do video calls, todo apps, etc. Even Google photos casually asked me to add my SO so they can view my photos.

I think that most people could do all of that adfree without installing another app.

The innovation would just be centralization. Which only benefits the company centralizing.

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by amvalo on Saturday April 14, 2018 @06:18PM (#16839861)
Or... you could just have a conversation like normal people.
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by Aditya_Garg on Saturday April 14, 2018 @06:27PM (#16839911)
He's saying more along the lines of having a social media profile (like Facebook) that represents 2 people.
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by amvalo on Saturday April 14, 2018 @07:51PM (#16840271)
That actually doesn't seem to be what he's saying. "Share grocery lists." That's what a couple would share with each other, not to their other friends.

> my partner likes a Chanel purse on FB or Pinterest the partner app let's me know

And seriously, it sounds awful. This is how you expect technology to benefit humanity?

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by goatherders on Saturday April 14, 2018 @11:10PM (#16840926)
Yes. And what's wrong with that? Until the brightest minds apply themselves to solving real problems the least they can do is solve small problems instead of making solutions for problems that dont exist.
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by goatherders on Saturday April 14, 2018 @08:56PM (#16840487)
Or you could kiss my ass and stop being snippy. Online interaction is not exclusive to conversation and intimacy. I dont have time or inclination (nor does she) to sit on the couch and say "look at this photo I took at lunch" or "what does next weeks evening calendar look like.."

An app could solve that. Well.

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by amvalo on Saturday April 14, 2018 @09:52PM (#16840649)
You don't have time to sit on a couch and talk about your day together?
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by collyw on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:52AM (#16842138)
Have you never been to a restaurant and see a couple together more interested in their phones than each other.

(A casual observation of mine is that it is usually better looking couples that do this, but not exclusively. Maybe the constant need to be on social media forces them to pay more attention to their appearance and less on their conversation).

Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by goatherders on Saturday April 14, 2018 @11:08PM (#16840920)
Of course we do. And that's for the important stuff. Social media is largely garbage so sharing the small stuff would be useful.
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by blowski on Saturday April 14, 2018 @06:45PM (#16839999)
Re:The Secret to Better Social Media? Fewer Friends by giancarlostoro on Saturday April 14, 2018 @07:04PM (#16840080)
There's a bunch. Even Avocado IO but some suffer from laggy chat. Once you got enough messages the app takes forever as it tries to download every single message. Skype has the same damn problem... Just sync the last 10 then slowly poll for the rest and poll the rest fully if I scroll up... Never understood why they did that.