EX: I thought the twitter people where idiots so I codded up an outline for a solution that would fix their basic problem. I quickly got to single threaded code that was significantly faster than what they used and reasonable memory efficient so I stopped. However, it's not exactly a hard problem and it's not production worthy so I feel no reason to share it with other people.
One simple example, if I'm writing a utility to be used by me alone, I probably don't verify input. I don't do very good error handling (if it crashes who cares), etc, but if I were hiring the lack of any of these would be a serious red flag to me in any submitted code sample.
Of course there are larger personal projects were a little more care is taken, but it is a whole other level of polish that I put into professional work. I would be embarrassed to share my personal projects. That's probably actually a good sign because at least I know it should be better.
as an interviewer I'd be skeptical if the interviewee not only was secretive about his/her code, but had no pet projects or toy scripts lying about.
I think it's a great question because not only do you get a quick sense for how people code, but the response choice itself gives you some insight in to how people think and what gets them excited about hacking.