Re:How to Be a Systems Thinker
by fallous on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:04AM
(#16835983)
The "desktop metaphor" is a conceit, in the literary sense, that provides a general structure to a presentation but it isn't truly useful as a means of conveying the logic or expectations of a system in the way that an analogy provides.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How to Be a Systems Thinker
by hyperpallium on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:08AM
(#16835995)
An aspect that does is the position of a mouse on a desktop with the position of a cursor on the screen.
Except that the "desktop metaphor" stops being a "desktop" with the introduction of a cursor and mouse. Actual desktops are manipulated directly by users... and desktops don't allow you to move your hand all the way to the right and magically move to a new clean desk (in the case of virtual windows). There's nothing about a desktop that infers the behaviors described which is why it's crappy for conveying the actual behaviors of current UI... hence the limited nature of metaphor.
Re:How to Be a Systems Thinker
by justinjlynn on Saturday April 14, 2018 @03:43AM
(#16836354)
Given an appropriate physical implementation of a desk, more aspects the desktop metaphor could certainly be implemented. Typically metaphors allude to the platonic ideal of something and not any one concrete instance of a given subject.