Re:PHP On Pie takes a fresh new approach.
by mcantelon on Sunday September 12, 2010 @02:28AM
(#1683182)
It's inverse is extract(). What's icky about using compact()?
Re:PHP On Pie takes a fresh new approach.
by photon_off on Sunday September 12, 2010 @04:28AM
(#1683305)
Whenever reflection can be avoided, it should be. What makes it icky is that developers then need to worry about how they name their variables. It shouldn't be a problem so long there's a convention established.
Personally, when passing a lot of parameters, I condense them into a "Holder" class:
$holder->var1 = "foo";
$holder->var2 = "foo";
//or set from array
$holder->addArray(array("var1"=>"foo", "var2"=>"foo"));
//later on, retrieving values
$holder->useStrictMode(true); //optional: throws exception if key isn't present (rather than returning null)
echo $holder->var1;
echo $holder->var2;
echo $holder->var3; //throws exception that var3 was expected to be present
It's worked well for me. It's also very handy for returning multiple values and status codes.
Re:PHP On Pie takes a fresh new approach.
by mcantelon on Sunday September 12, 2010 @05:26PM
(#1684592)
>What makes it icky is that developers then need to worry about how they name their variables.
Good point.
Because it's highly dependent on scope? Like, if I wanted to template each list item in an array, I could use array_map with another template function, but here I would have to keep re-assigning a variable in a foreach.
And it seems to be unclear on how you'd pass array and object members to it? It seems very much to encourage variable creep?
Re:PHP On Pie takes a fresh new approach.
by mcantelon on Sunday September 12, 2010 @05:28PM
(#1684594)
>if I wanted to template each list item in an array, I could use array_map with another template function
Good point.
I think you mean "extract", not "explode". And no, it's not icky. It's a very nice construct by PHP, to avoid having to write:
array ('foo' => $foo, 'bar' => $bar, ...)
and just write
compact('foo', 'bar')
what's wrong with that? :)
About the event system: Thanks man, I put a lot of effort into it. It's way faster than the drupal system, and also more extensible.
Starting off the 'Technology' tab with supported OSes and servers couldn't be a good idea: those familiar with PHP will understand that incompatible with a system on which PHP is supported is a bug, but compatibility within PHP is obvious.
That said, the event system is interesting, and might be a good rethink of the Drupal hook system.