Re:This is engineering: Army Jeep torn apart and reassembled...
by CamperBob on Saturday September 11, 2010 @07:26PM
(#1682611)
Try doing major repairs at the side of the road with people shooting at you, and you'll appreciate the design.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:This is engineering: Army Jeep torn apart and reassembled...
by sandeepshetty on Saturday September 11, 2010 @08:13PM
(#1682685)
How does the ability to take a Jeep apart and reassemble it in 4 minutes (by 8+ guys) help you in "doing major repairs at the side of the road with people shooting at you"?
In a hostile context like you describe (if that's what this is meant for) don't you think there might be other design considerations?
Re:This is engineering: Army Jeep torn apart and reassembled...
by jhghjnmmn on Saturday September 11, 2010 @10:52PM
(#1682922)
The british army stick with a 10year old version of the land rover for the same reason - you don't want to be in a ditch in Afghanistan trying to fix a computerized engine management system with a hammer.
Re:This is engineering: Army Jeep torn apart and reassembled...
by sandeepshetty on Sunday September 12, 2010 @03:33AM
(#1683237)
The point I've been trying to make is that simplicity/great-design has a context and that context is missing in the original source. Everyone here seems to be adding context, but I have to take their word for it because they are not presenting it with any supporting facts. e.g., a reference to where the British army claims to be sticking with a 10yr old version of the land rover, to avoid having to deal with computerized engine management system malfunctions in hostile situations.
While I can see and agree with the point that people are making, I would just prefer if they were substantiated.