I really don't know any other real alternatives other than making the user pay, which would in turn make the internet just basically one big subscription model. The majority of the "free" services which many people enjoy now, like YouTube, Facebook, etc probably could not exist as they do.
What is needed is some clear boundaries (legislation), and education. I believe without advertising that the internet would not have been what it is today, and I don't think it would have exponentially better.
Again, for this customer...
I'm moving soon and seriously considering not signing up for internet at my new address (new job, I'll be at work a ton, and the common area has free wifi I could use for the occasional email or weekend netflix download). But I won't cancel my prime subscription. That's what made me realize how sticky amazon is: I will pay 3 figures for access, even without instant access to the network that lets me get to them!
We know exactly what the number is. Take Facebook’s revenue and divide it by their number of users.
Most users probably make facebook almost nothing, and then a smaller portion make them far more.
Free shipping isn't really free, the cost of a product can include multiple different factors.
As far as the annoyance point, I guess that is somewhat balanced out by the importance of the site.
But that isn't the point I was making, the point I am making is that advertising is genuine way for companies to make money from offering services. There isn't really any other valid alternatives to this over than user pays or giving it away.
For example, I would have no doubt the the customer acquisition cost for an "free" application with advertising is a lot lower than trying to sell that same user a membership.
When it comes to social networks I would suggest that the stickiness is because your friends/family etc are on the same network. It's not if you are willing to pay, it is only really worth it, if your friends are willing to pay.
If you are talking more about a paid and free version, then there are already services out there like YouTube Red (available in some areas for $9.99+ USD). There are always options out there.
https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/31/facebook-earnings-q4-2017-ar...
For comparison, this number just recently passed TV advertising, which is about $70B/yr ($217/person, $605/household).
It is an uncomfortable truth that we have yet to really contemplate as a society.
Consumerism ISN'T sustainable, and society will grow to a point where we are going to see seemingly fundamental systems start to crumble beneath the sheer weight of consumption.
We have to be willing to ask "should we?" in addition to "can we?"
That doesn't have to be true. Done right, ads can be about making more people aware of a product, to reach people who genuinely benefit from it but would not otherwise have heard about it. That's the advertising future I'd like to see, even if it's not how things are right now.
The argument that ads are about informing consumer just doesn’t stand up to reality. The whole concept is flawed.
That's a common cultural belief that I do not subscribe to, seems to come with our currently trendy variants of capitalism/liberalism. I personally belief it is more akin to a crime that is currently not punished.
> probably could not exist as they do.
More industries have been outlawed in history.
> I believe without advertising that the internet would not have been what it is today,
I can take that as fact. But I do not think that "without ads" (on the internet or not) is "economically worse". I think without ads we would produce better quality; it's complete guessing, but that's just my expectation.
Given how much Microsoft has been pushing ads in W10, we're not going to see this push coming from Microsoft anytime soon.
If all advertising disappeared tomorrow, the world would function better. Consumers would not have advertisers trying to manipulate them, and they would more rationally allocate their resources.
Advertising is a tax placed on people who have already bought a product, which made it more expensive, to manipulate other people into also buying that same product.
Without it, good products would succeed on merit / independent reviews / word of mouth.
* The one exception I can think of is possibly during the scale period of startups, helping them scale faster (artificially) than if they just followed the "be the best and it will catch on" approach.
I'd love to not play the advertising game, but marketing seems to be one of the most important parts of running a business, if not the most important part, and it'll get its grimy hands on anything to acquire users. I'd prefer to avoid the world where they pay people to post rave reviews in HN comments to hype products.
I don't buy it. Advertising is not going to provide me with the service that is the most suited to my need, or with the best value. In fact, quite the opposite: the advertisement that's the most likely to reach me comes from the company with the largest budget for advertisement. That budget eats into either the profit of the company or into the quality of service delivered.
In short, there’s nothing inevitable about advertising models as they exist today, and people who try to convince of you that they are inevitable are peobsbly trying to sow apathy.
This is of course selection buas.
Here’s my hunch on what would happen: we would realize that it’s really messed up that the only options for people to get basic services we once took for granted is to pay for it; and those that can’t afford it must give up their privacy or start rationing a budget to access news, email etc. for a fee.
On Maslows hierarchy, privacy in the sense of ad targeting is a pretty privileged need. The business model works for the overwhelming majority of the world; it’s only broken for people who think it’s no big deal to have to shell a few bucks extra a month for either more privacy or access to services (that would no longer exist for free to the extent they do today.)
You still get ads on very expensive cable TV packages.
Your bank still data mines and sells off your purchase history, dispite a large monthly fee.
What if the social network user agreement contained "privacy" provisions prohibiting collecting data if the user pays a fee but no such "privacy" provisions if the user pays nothing.
To do what?
In case you ever stopped paying; and because stopping displaying ads _and_ stopping tracking was more work than just stopping display.Because it's not the showing of ads that's the real problem, it's the harvesting of demographic/interest/PII from the graph that's the problem. So they "can't" offer a way to opt out of that because for the part of your network that doesn't opt out, advertisers would have much less good data (ergo FB's value prop to advertisers is much less good) since it wouldn't have the data from the graph to augment the user's own data.
Facebook would be faced with trying to get as much revenue out of the 5% of their users who pay as out of the currently-100% of users who don't, and that would be a very hard thing to do.
- Making ads relevant means less ads overall for the user
- It would cost $20 / year and no studies show that users would pay anywhere near that. It reasonable to assume its impractical
- Subscription-premium services rely on a small number of fans to pony up (usually significantly) for the rest of users. afaik facebook does not have such a mass of hardcore, passionate fans.
- More generally there is no evidence that subscription users are happier.
Would other Facebook apps still have as wide an array of data on users that we've seen? And if apps can see it then Facebook itself is still gathering it... even if ads aren't targeted.
What's the point of advertising to people who can't afford to pay a few bucks for a social networking site? If they're broke they aren't going to buy anything anyway.
I think this whole train of thought is a logical fallacy. You need people who have more money than sense to believe that not paying is a better option than paying. It's a con.
It depends on what is being "advertised". To give one example, it might be an "issue ad", not for a commercial product/service. The "ad" can be thought of as a general form of persuasion to adopt some mode of thinking and consequently some specific action or inaction.
According to the whistleblower testimony, these were the type of ads being shown in certain third world countries by the companies who utilised the Facebook user data.
The minority of people on Facebook that click on ads and buy things, are making it possible for the other 2 billion people to use the service without paying a monthly fee.
This distribution is identical to advertising pretty much everywhere else throughout history.
Everyone that drives by a billboard can't afford to buy what the billboard is selling. That doesn't make it a con. The buyers you do derive, out of the very large number of people that have no interest or can't afford what you're selling, pay for your billboard (hopefully).
Everyone that watches an ad on TV - the past half century - can't afford to buy the thing being sold (a $1,000 workout machine), that doesn't mean the advertising is a con.
The sole difference is the heightened targeting based on information that Facebook or Google know about your habits or interests. In the past, it was far more difficult. A TV advertiser for example, might discover through research and trial & error that TV watchers are more likely to buy that $1,000 workout machine at 1am via an hour long infomercial. The experimentation loop was dramatically slower.
There's also a very very "fat head" in front of the long tail of what customers pay FB et al for their ads.
https://www.wordstream.com/articles/most-expensive-keywords
Suggests the 10 most expensive categories to advertise in are dominated by insurance, financial, and legal services.
I suspect when that curve is overlaid with the similar long tail curve of the disposable income of FB's 2 billion users - I suspect it'd be obvious that the vast majority of FBs income comes from super expensive PPC ads shown to people with a (globally) super high disposable income.
If you let the bay area tech crowd who're struggling to find a place to rent on their own because they're "only" making $160k all opt out of getting profiles and shown advertising for $25 or $50 per month, you'd probably make a existential dent in FB's profitability - much more so than if they just turned advertising off altogether for the lowest earning billion and a half people on their platform.
this totally nullifies the purpose of a advertising based business model.
TV channels i pay for them and still they show advertisement.
i can afford and i pay for them and am ok with negligible nonsense here and there, and am only going to switch to other channels when an advertisement seems to begin.
i am sure 70% ppl are capable of going and finding wat they want. and the rest of them wont buy stuff any ways just because they saw an ad.
May b this whole advertisement caters to those 2 or 3 percent of entire population who are cat on the wall.
However, that is an argument favoring the customer, i.e., the advertiser, not the product, i.e., the user.
During the Senate hearing, he was asked about Ms. Sandberg's comment that if there were no ads then users would have to pay. Mr. Zuckerberg pointed out that users can opt-out of ad targeting/data collection,[1] making the ads they receive more generic and less "relevant", but currently Facebook offers no option for users to pay not to receive any ads at all.
The still unasked question is, "Why not?"
If some users could not afford to pay, as Mr. Zuckerberg suggested in both hearings, then they could opt-in to advertising. How would this affect the business model?
Further, if those users were disappointed at how the ads they were being shown were not "relevant", then they could opt-in to ad targeting/data collection.
1. The default setting is opt-in. As we know, most users do not change default settings.