News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by nickysielicki on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:12AM (#16820523)
This is not so different from the arguments behind what motivated the Unabomber. One key difference is that Ted Kaczynski saw it as necessarily political.

People should read Kaczynski's manifesto. It's rough at parts, but it's really an interesting perspective.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/unabo...

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by clarkevans on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:51AM (#16820871)
It's a fundamentally pessimistic essay, offering no workable solution to the articulated challenges other than a complete rejection of technology.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by buvanshak on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:57AM (#16822226)
>It's a fundamentally pessimistic essay...

Why is future optimistic by default? By the way humanity is progressing, do you see any reason for hope? Do you disagree that we are in a technological runaway?

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by Sileni on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:40PM (#16822614)
No, but it's the same argument for something like SpaceX. A quick analysis says being optimistic makes the most sense because it has the best outcomes in all situations.

If we're optimistic and correct, we're building the things that will be useful in the future. We know we have to get off the planet to survive as a species, so we have to hope that we can do so.

If we're optimistic and wrong, we're distracting ourselves until we die. Pessimistic and correct, we wait for death and die.

Pessimistic and incorrect, we watch the future run away from us while we argue over what remains on the planet to be used by the technology we stagnated in. I don't want to know what 2050 looks like if we're still dependent on oil.

The worst case only exists if we're pessimistic as a species. The best case only exists if we're optimistic.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by buvanshak on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:52PM (#16823259)
It did't ask if being pessimistic is useful. I asked if future looks hopeful for you, from where we are standing right now..
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by Sileni on Thursday April 12, 2018 @05:51PM (#16825218)
And I'm saying we're fallible. We need mechanisms to avoid fatalism when looking at a downward slope, because history says we don't actually know how things will turn out, no matter how obvious they seem.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by 3pt14159 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:58AM (#16820941)
I read it long ago and came to the conclusion that he was essentially right with how he framed the problem but the solution he picked out of the two alternatives was the wrong one. Running away from technological progress into the wilderness somewhere might be good for you but the only long term solution that is good for everyone is to alter humanity to be better adapted to its new environment.

Though there are probably a multitude of ways of doing it, the two that stick out as most likely / agreeable to all are Gattaca and AI + Cyborg. Though I could also see strong AI either just replacing humanity[0] or simulating / uploading the minds of the good humans and merging with them.

[0] I'm not convinced that this would be a bad thing, a hypothetical AI that comes with all of the benefits of humanity with none of the rape or war might just be better ethically in a global sense.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by ionised on Thursday April 12, 2018 @10:11AM (#16821064)
Got to the bit about 'leftists' and then had to roll my eyes and close the page.

It's stereotypical generalising of entire segments of the population into a straw-man caricature he can rage and rant against.

Honestly, I believe anyone who still thinks in traditional terms of left/right politically, isn't adding anything worthwhile to the discussion.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by 131012 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:54AM (#16820906)
An ideology that requires killing random people always seems flawed to me.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:01AM (#16821622)
This is a nonsensical comment. He used bombs to gain the notoriety to get published in the New York Times.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by manjushri on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:27PM (#16822494)
Is there a prominent ideology that hasn't lead to murders?