News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by makomk on Thursday April 12, 2018 @08:48AM (#16820292)
What you're basically saying, I think, is that there shouldn't be any easy way for ordinary people to communicate directly with each other and organise politically. That it's too dangerous to allow them to do this without the press acting as gatekeepers first. That certainly does seem to be the underlying subtext of a lot of the recent criticism of Facebook. It's also an astounding line of thinking, because it basically says that it's politically unacceptable, even a danger to democracy, for ordinary people to actually have power and not just the illusion that they do.

(Edit: to be fair, I should probably add that the press wouldn't be the only powerful institution that has the ability to enable or gatekeep activism and organising, just one of the most important. The more fundamental difference is whether you need to have one of those powerful institutions backing your cause.)

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by DanielBMarkham on Thursday April 12, 2018 @08:56AM (#16820372)
Thanks for your comment because I am not saying that at all.

All I'm saying is that a certain amount of friction is a necessary part of our survival as a species. I'm not making any comments about the press or people organizing or any of that.

Some message boards, including HN, have a delay between the time you read a comment and when you are allowed to form a reply. This cuts way back on flame wars. It's also a nice example of purposely introducing some friction for a larger good.

I don't know how much friction is needed or where it should go. I'm just now reaching the conclusion about Facebook and social media. This utopia they've all been preaching is actually a dystopia, a horrible thing indeed. I'm nowhere near having any thoughts about a solution.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by wpietri on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:57AM (#16820929)
One interesting book in this context is Neiwart's "Alt America". [1] Neiwart is a journalist who spent decades tracking the armed US fringe, including the "patriot" militias, sovereign citizen movements, conspiracists, and white supremacist groups.

It's his view that the alt right didn't come out of nowhere. Instead, the low-friction communication of the Internet allowed these formerly scattered, always-falling-apart groups to connect and recruit in ways that were previously impossible.

I also don't think it's a coincidence that the rise of the alt-right happened when social media companies in some sense took friction negative. In the world of websites and blogs, you at least had to actively seek the next site, the next writer, the next article. It wasn't much work, but it was at least a little.

Youtube, Facebook, and Twitter were eager to give you an endless stream of content, so as to maximize User Active Minutes metrics. So their algorithms would pull up anything that they thought you'd be interested in. The theory being that any engagement must be good, which implies that total obsession would be best.

In retrospect, that theory seems to have some flaws.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by DanielBMarkham on Thursday April 12, 2018 @10:03AM (#16820998)
If you'd like to join me in speculating a bit, let's take an imaginary look at ten years from now.

Good news! AI has advanced enough that it is now possible for you to have a customized bot that handles all of the crappy and mundane parts of life: scheduling travel, getting groceries, making sure the house is clean, and so on. The bot learns about you and is able to anticipate your needs.

And because we have this tech, we also have bots that will play your emotions like a finely-tuned fiddle. Think Elvis never died? Afraid that lizard-people in the government are controlling your thoughts? Well, now there's a bot that will find others like you and deliver to you a continuous stream of information confirming your beliefs -- and warning you of the dangers lurking out there.

Now guess which of these bots makes more money for its creators, the one scheduling airline flights or the one keeping you emotionally-connected with 400 people just like you and making sure that all of you are living a dramatic life on the edge where you're fighting the bad guys?

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by wpietri on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:36PM (#16823135)
Definitely. It's the kind of manipulative dystopia that might have been designed by timeshare salesmen and propagandists. But the weird part to me is that conscious design seems basically unnecessary. It's dystopia metastasized.

I've interviewed the occasional person looking to leave Facebook, and one of the surprising things to me is how small everybody's job is. They're all optimizing micro-metrics for micro-gains, with very little thought as to the systemic impact. Those micro-metrics in turn roll up to plausible-sounding things like revenue, DAU, time on site, and engagement. Yay engagement! How could that be bad?

But I've never heard anybody from Facebook, employee or exec, say, "Gosh, could we be acting like tobacco company execs or slot machine designers?" They don't even seem to understand addiction as a topic, let alone a concern. It's very much as Upton Sinclair said: "“It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by michaelfeathers on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:13PM (#16823996)
I think it's because we don't understand systems as well as we should. This article (http://www.miamiherald.com/news/business/article207841309.ht...) is a decent intro to what modeling shows about engagement and polarization. The paper it refers to (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.06009.pdf) goes way deeper.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by manjushri on Thursday April 12, 2018 @10:43AM (#16821419)
So it seems the theory here is that strong AI whose primary objective is to make money is ultimately self destructive?
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by cwkoss on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:04PM (#16823919)
This is basically the state of Twitter today.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by essayist on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:21AM (#16821860)
Clay Shirky pointed out a while ago that the power of the Internet to connect previously isolated individuals with common interests can have the downside of making that common interest seem more normal to those people.

E.g. if I'm the only Nazi I know, there's no one to buck me up and so maybe I consider that there's something wrong with my beliefs. But add a convenient subreddit, facebook page, etc. and I get to think that there are lots of us. (We conveniently forget about the denominator.)

This phenomenon is great for society when it comes to sufferers of rare diseases, the lonely, closeted gay kid in a small town, and cult film lovers. Not so great when it comes to racists etc.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by ManFromUranus on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:57AM (#16822218)
It cuts both ways though, you can't have your cake and eat it too. A counter example: if I'm the only guy I know that thinks Jim Crow laws are bad and there's nobody around to buck me up, so maybe I consider that there's something wrong with my beliefs.

If you police speech for some people and not others you will create problems, either you think that people are inherently good (therefore everbody should be able to speak until they reveal otherwise) or some kind of top down censorship should be in place to keep things "civil", now the problem is who gets to decide what "civil" is.

So its better and easier and more robust to just let people say what they want to say (even if bad) and just allow people to filter out what they don't want.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by essayist on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:02PM (#16823358)
We mostly agree, see my last paragraph.

Further, "collecting" a group of scattered folks with common interests can be good even if their common interest isn't. E.g. I know that there are "cutting" and self-harm websites, and of course the practice of self-harm is awful, but those websites may be a way to reach people and help them.

As to what to regulate, I think that the anti-Holocaust denial laws in Europe make a more fraught case than anti-child pornography. Child pornography generally hurts kids even if it's not circulated.

Denying the Holocaust is stupid and offensive and upsetting to many, but it doesn't harm the speaker or the listener in the same way. I don't know, one way or another, whether these laws have led to "slippery slopes".

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by wpietri on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:27PM (#16823075)
It does cut both ways, but that doesn't justify your "let people say what they want no matter how awful it is" conclusion.

At the margins it's certainly hard to tell sort-of-bad content from not-so-bad content. But that doesn't mean we can't find pretty clear examples. Banning child pornography, for example, doesn't seem to have harmed freedom of speech much.

You also ignore that what speech we allow influences what people will say at all. For example, if we allow violent threats and harassment (which are both definitely speech), this will be used to silence voices. And in the American context, it's pretty clear which voices get silenced. Which voices have been silenced for decades and decades.

So in practice, somebody will always be silenced on some topics. The question is more who gets silenced, and what kind of environment for discussion we want to create.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by ManFromUranus on Thursday April 12, 2018 @04:53PM (#16824842)
I don't think that child pornography falls under speech at all, and I don't see the connection. Child pornography sole purpose is to serve prurient interests.

Sorry I don't mean to say that speech should be a free for all, threats will not be tolerated, nor would harassment, but we already have longstanding laws and procedures to deal with those things, they are nothing new.

"it's pretty clear which voices get silenced. Which voices have been silenced for decades and decades"

I don't think it's clear at all, nobody is currently being silenced, however I can see the pattern of existing laws and policies around harassment and threats being misused to silence political opponents. This is a very bad development, and mostly recent phenomenon. I think as far as thats concerned we have crossed the rubicon so to speak, and the polarization will only accelerate.

"So in practice, somebody will always be silenced on some topics."

I don't agree. Even child pornography can be discussed however children have no agency and can't consent to their images being used in such a way. So it can never be legalized. There are many subjects that cannot be discussed (racial issues, social issues) that are considered by the left to be unmentionable even though points expressed are perfectly respectful and salient.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by wpietri on Thursday April 12, 2018 @06:53PM (#16825692)
You should read a little more history.

The US has a long track record of violence, threat of violence, and social power being used to suppress women and black people, for example. The #MeToo campaign happened recently not because women weren't being sexually exploited in the past, but because their power has finally grown enough that some of them can start to speak with less fear of consequence.

Studies show that this power imbalance continues online. Accounts with female and/or black get a lot more crap. Crap that acts to suppress not just the people receiving it, but anybody who sees it happen and thinks they might become a target of it.

So if you're running a platform, you have a pretty clear choice. Somebody's getting silenced. The question is whether you let the people who want to silence others run rampant, or whether you protect the voices they're trying to suppress.

And I'd add that the left talks about racial and social issues quite a bit, so I think your characterization there is at best misleading.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by CM30 on Friday April 13, 2018 @08:26AM (#16829298)
Personally, I wonder if it's had the opposite effect to some degree. Namely, because it's so easy to find people with views you find reprehensible, you think those views are more common than they actually are and that everything's getting worse as a result. Groups and individuals who'd never usually encounter each other are now seeing their enemies more than ever...
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:10AM (#16820509)
There are ways in which humans self-organise, amplifying individual intelligence and empathy, and ways in which humans self-disorganise, amplifying the naive ambition, greed, and poor choices of powerful individuals.

The challenge is to distinguish between the two.

The FB memo is self-serving nonsense, because it tries to deny there's a problem. In fact the problem existed outside FB before FB and the rest were created.

Why do we have an economy in which a social network exists primarily to amplify the power of persuasive media? Why do our political fitness functions reward this outcome, instead of the other possible outcomes that social networks could generate?

This isn't a problem that can be fixed with more or better software, because it's not a technical problem - it's about politics and values, and how our political economy rewards certain behaviours while punishing, or at least strongly disincentivising, others.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by cousin_it on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:22AM (#16820600)
Yeah. I felt much more free and creative when writing LiveJournal posts, which were guaranteed to be seen by my 10-100ish "friends", than when writing Reddit or HN posts, which must compete with tons of other posts to get seen by 0-infinity people.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by dfsegoat on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:53AM (#16820896)
If I understand what you are saying, I think I might be able to give a personal anecdote to show that most definitely, some "friction" is required to get people organizing and socializing as they traditionally would (outside of social media), and why social media isn't enough:

In October 2017, my area was hit by the worst wildfires in California history. For days, there was no power, there was no internet (mobile or otherwise), there was no 911. We had AM/FM radio and our neighbors.

For all intents and purposes, we were back to the 1900s.

What happened? Well, people in my neighborhood (neighbors) who were all on edge - who had LARGELY ONLY EVER INTERACTED VIA SOCIAL MEDIA (myNextDoor and facebook) - suddenly found that SOCIAL MEDIA wasn't enough.

Within hours, people were organizing and talking, and sharing information in the streets. I met most of my neighbors that week that we had to go without internet access - people I have lived next to for 5 years now, but never had a conversation with. Literally everyone kept to themselves and used MyNextDoor as a proxy for traditional interaction.

Also, social media became toxic during this event - False information was spread rapidly in unofficial groups, evacuation orders which were never issued were reported as fact, etc. Our local PD ended up putting out 24x7 hourly updates to stop the flow of bad information.

TL;DR: During the October 2017 wildfires, power and internet were out for days -- the "friction" of this event (plus limited access) showed me that people in crisis / who need to organize can't do so via social media alone. Inevitably, small groups of neighbors organized physically to help ea. other out - and the disaster was the catalyst for this.

Edit 1 - Added notes on bad parts of social media during natural disaster.

PS: Apologies for the length. This was a traumatic event, and verbalizing this here has been therapeutic.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by crusty on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:09AM (#16820503)
I didn't read that. Organizing a union or a political or social movement occur through deliberate, thoughtful efforts. I took his comment to indicate something along the lines of; Mobs (IRL or digital) are emotion driven and feed off of (or even are dependent upon) instantaneous, omni-directional communication. Maybe adding friction to communication has historically had the benefit of reducing mob tendencies. But friction does not mean prevented or blocked.

I haven't thought any of this over myself, but if I supported this idea, I'd offer that friction, in reducing mob tendencies, might actually make more room for the types of communications that promote rational democratic ideas.

Basically, i think you read way more into his idea of friction than was there.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by makomk on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:35AM (#16822016)
The ultimate problem I have with this idea is that it only makes creating structures slow, not actually taking action. (We lost the kind of friction that would slow down the latter around the time TV and radio appeared.) So even without social media we can have hasty, knee-jerk extreme reactions to pretty much anything, they just have to go through the established structure.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 12, 2018 @10:01AM (#16820982)
Yup. The way I see this is more like adding intertia in control systems - it makes a system a bit more sluggish, but can prevent it from oscillating out of control.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by ben_w on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:01AM (#16820418)
Interesting, I would agree with the conclusion without the intermediary.

I don’t trust the press to do a better job of this than anyone else. The press is made of people and subject to the same flaws and desire for power — both to campaign for the freedom to do certain things, and also to restrict other things (I’m thinking of UK issues like fox hunting and one particular moral panic about the drug MDMA that turned out to be a water overdose).

That said, like the two famous Churchil quotes on democracy, I’ll say both that the best argument against democracy is a five minute conversation with the average voter, yet also that democracy is the worst form of government except for all the others. I can see democracy’s flaws, but not how to fix them. I wouldn’t even want to be in a benevolent dictatorship if I was running it.

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by makomk on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:10AM (#16820507)
I certainly don't trust the press to do a better job of this than anyone else, and they definitely don't do a great job of encouraging deliberation and slowness to act - if anything the exact opposite. This is more of a practical observation of how things actually are and what the actual end result of this would look like. There hasn't been the same kind of push to stamp down on hasty, mob-like action backed by the press as there has been to restrict social media and direct unmediated communication, and I can't see any such push going anywhere given the amount of media pushback that would result.

(Also, to be fair, I should probably have extended this to other powerful institutions and organisations with the ability to mediate what kinds of activism can and cannot happen, not just the press. Meant to but it didn't make it into my original comment.)

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by canoebuilder on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:56PM (#16823855)
>What you're basically saying, I think, is that there shouldn't be any easy way for ordinary people to communicate directly with each other and organise politically.

This isn't an either/or.

There's a world of possibility you're missing.

Like, people should be able to freely communicate online, but maybe not on platforms that psychologically exploit them for ad revenue (and other, potentially nefarious, aims should the wrong person get hands on the levers.)

Re:The high modernism of social media companies by cirgue on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:29AM (#16821949)
Facebook is designed to incentivize vitriol and dramatic interactions and actively prevents uniting around common interests. Facebook is a massive obstacle to robust political organization.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by JoeAltmaier on Thursday April 12, 2018 @08:52AM (#16820330)
No, they've always been able to do what you say, even before these apps. The issue is the speed at which it happens, turns ordinary sensible people into members of a mob. That's clearly a problem.
Re:The high modernism of social media companies by crdoconnor on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:23AM (#16820621)
>That certainly does seem to be the underlying subtext of a lot of the recent criticism of Facebook. It's also an astounding line of thinking, because it basically says that it's politically unacceptable, even a danger to democracy

I noticed this too. I presumed it's just the media reacting to its declining influence and facebook's increasing power over what we see.

I've also noticed a lot of hand wringing about "facebook fake news" and the importance of "responsible journalism" from the likes of the New York Times and Washington Post as if none of use remember them (among other things) vigorously beating the Iraq war drum with equally fake news in 2003.

On the one hand they've got a point. On the other hand it should be just about anybody else except them making that point.