News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is in the privacy spotlight but should Google be... by ocdtrekkie on Thursday April 12, 2018 @08:34AM (#16820189)
Google is its own third party: There is no appreciable difference between Facebook sharing your data with an ad company and Google sharing your data with their own built-in ad company.
Re:Facebook is in the privacy spotlight but should Google be... by matlin on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:41AM (#16820781)
There definitely is... That's the whole point of Facebook's Senate hearing. If it stays within company and can't be used by directly by third parties for their own agendas like influencing elections. I 100% think that we should be weary of over centralized information but we are talking about two very different scenarios: even a small social network with relatively little information can be very dangerous if it leaks personal data.
Re:Facebook is in the privacy spotlight but should Google be... by jacquesm on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:45AM (#16820807)
Please stop spreading factually wrong information, especially on a subject as important as this one. Maybe research the material for a bit? The best place to start is doubleclick and their profiling options as well as the RTB spec. That will give you a pretty shocking (if I understand the level to which you are still in the dark correctly) insight into what kind of data is freely shared between ad tech companies amongst each other and their customers (agencies, advertisers).
Re:Facebook is in the privacy spotlight but should Google be... by matlin on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:36PM (#16823138)
I understand that you are angry about the Cambridge Analytica revelations, I am too. But I am not spreading misinformation, I am participating in a discussion. I have repeatedly try to communicate that I am not talking about targeted advertising. In the senate hearing, the counsel is honing on some important points. What is the alternative to Facebook (i.e. a real competitor)? What information is Facebook gathering on non-users? What is Facebook doing to shield users' from the outside world? How much metadata is Facebook gathering/surmising outside of a user's direct input? These are way bigger questions than does Facebook allow Advertisers to target you based on certain demographics (a similar but different debate). Google is poised to abuse / misuse personal data in the same way but regulating and persecuting are very different processes and should not be conflated in these discussions. I simply want to draw those distinctions between Google and Facebook.
Re:Facebook is in the privacy spotlight but should Google be... by jacquesm on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:43PM (#16823192)
It's all targeted advertising so if you want to make the case that outside of targeted advertising Google is squeaky clean then you're welcome to that but it's a rather narrow definition for what arguably is the largest advertising company in the world.

They exist because of and for targeted advertising, everything else is just a means of getting there.

Re:Facebook is in the privacy spotlight but should Google be... by ocdtrekkie on Thursday April 12, 2018 @10:17AM (#16821138)
You do realize that Google has it's own reasons for wanting to influence elections, right? They operate their own PAC and spend millions of dollars donating to political candidates and lobbyist groups.

"Within company" is a meaningless distinction. It requires the assumption that Facebook or Google themselves are trustworthy, and smaller companies are not. But the big players themselves, are in fact, not trustworthy. So whether or not they sell the data or abuse it in-house is pretty much irrelevant.

Re:Facebook is in the privacy spotlight but should Google be... by matlin on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:47PM (#16822686)
Obviously but you're missing the main focus which is privacy and responsibility of holding personal data. It's not about whether Facebook is more or less trustworthy than Google--I think we should be very wary of both. All I'm saying is when you give your data to a company it should stay within those walls and be clear how is used. It's one thing if Facebook or Google is influencing elections (which every major corporation tries to do with money, power, and/or information) it's about allowing third parties to abuse that power indiscriminately which Facebook did and Google did not.