Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by hansen on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @05:12PM
(#16815708)
> enhance the user experience
Sorry, but this made me laugh.
> whats the alternative to 3rd party cookies?
Don't use a 3rd party service.
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by devmunchies on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @06:58PM
(#16816537)
yes, saving user progress is enhancing their experience. you hear 3rd party and immediately think its bad.
> Don't use a 3rd party service.
I knew someone would say this, as if I had unlimited dev time.
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by mcpherrinm on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @09:38PM
(#16817341)
The third party service can provide you with some JavaScript you inject into your website. It stores cookies on your domain instead of a third party one.
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by yetanother1980 on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @11:06PM
(#16817673)
Which of course begs the question should third party scripts be allowed to run?
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by mcpherrinm on Saturday April 14, 2018 @11:08PM
(#16840917)
You don't need cross-origin scripts for this: you can host it yourself.
If you were to disallowed loading scripts cross-origin, everyone would just end up creating subdomains for everything you wanted to load, which would be worse security-wise I bet, as you'd lose some of the cross origin security features we have today.
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by hansen on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @09:51PM
(#16817388)
You shouldn't use the term enhancing user experience. It’s a
synonym for doing something against the interest of the user.
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by blacksmith_tb on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @05:28PM
(#16815863)
I think the traditional approach is to make them 1st-party, by setting up a subdomain, like '3rdparty.yourdomain.com' and forward requests to it to '3rdparty.com.'
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by ben509 on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @05:29PM
(#16815869)
Microservices. You track state yourself, call their service and shuttle the data back and forth, all on your servers. The user touches one endpoint and sees one cert.
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by sp332 on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @05:43PM
(#16816029)
Can you store user progress in the cookie, or Local Storage etc, instead of involving a third party?
Re:Web Browsers Reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies
by devmunchies on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @06:59PM
(#16816552)
its for things that are ephemeral and nice-to-have for the user but not worth it for me to build myself when there are more important things to work on. dang, i had a nice thing going.
Bad actors are making it harder for people who want to use cookies for enhancing the experience rather than analytics and marketing.