Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by kristianc on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @03:54PM
(#16814842)
I wouldn't rule that out. Martha Stewart survived a stint in prison.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by pb on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @04:01PM
(#16814926)
There is no comparison between the two. Martha Stewart was running a real business and made the mistake of talking to police without a lawyer -- that's very different from running a giant sham operation that defrauded many.
Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by oh_sigh on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @06:01PM
(#16816149)
The mistake she made was not that she talked to police without a lawyer, but that she lied to investigators. Yes, I'm sure the lawyer would not have let her make up those lies, but it's not like she just behaved well and got railroaded some how. And I never understood why she lied in the first place. If your paid broker gives you a tip that a CEO is dumping his shares, are you not allowed to act on it?
Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by emiliobumachar on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @06:26PM
(#16816312)
Some interrogators are really good at phrasing and intoning a question making it seem like they're inquiring about something very wrong, worth trying to cover up, e.g., "you didn't have any information about XYZ selling his shares, did you?" It shouldn't work if the target is thinking straight, but the whole point is to trigger a knee-jerk emotional reaction.
Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by oh_sigh on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @07:39PM
(#16816798)
Martha Stewart wholesale lied by saying that she and her broker had a pre-set price point of $60 for when to dump ImClone. That part is completely fabricated by Stewart. It's impossible to mess up 'My stock broker told me CEO was dumping his shares' with 'We agreed to sell at $60'
Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by celim307 on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @03:58PM
(#16814902)
Martha Stewart actually created products, and was good at it
Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by positr0n on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @03:58PM
(#16814901)
Yeah but insider trading is different than fraud. The line is blurry, but I'm sure everyone at that level has some level of inside knowledge they have traded on at one time or another.
Holmes on the other hand was directly defrauding investors, why would you want her on an executive team/board trying to get investments?
Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by scarmig on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @04:13PM
(#16815063)
Because she's a proven executor on defrauding investors?
Re:Theranos’ Letter to Shareholders Shows the Company Is on ...
by vkou on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @04:58PM
(#16815562)
The problem with insider trading is that it creates perverse incentives. It, in itself, does not necessarily defraud.
If I work for Apple, and I sneak a glance at their balance sheet, and short its stock, I did not rob APPL shareholders. It's still illegal, and insider trading (Because otherwise, I'd have an incentive to actively sink the company, while benefiting from a short.)