Re:PhD or Not PhD: that is the question
by gaius on Saturday September 11, 2010 @07:52AM
(#1681405)
Interesting what he says about US vs UK PhDs, given that Cambridge has just overtaken Harvard in the world rankings.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:PhD or Not PhD: that is the question
by imurray on Saturday September 11, 2010 @08:53AM
(#1681473)
I recommend the anonymous comment starting:
It's unfair to characterize a UK PhD as "a good US Master's thesis"...
http://matt-welsh.blogspot.com/2010/09/so-you-want-to-go-to-...
— it's pretty fair and accurate.
The thing with the UK system is we specialize a lot earlier. A 16 when you choose your A-levels you are already making choices, then you go to university to focus on one subject, there's no "choosing your major" after a year or two. And it's not even the case that the US system produces noticeably better generalists; UK people just pick that up as they go.
Re:PhD or Not PhD: that is the question
by imurray on Saturday September 11, 2010 @09:07AM
(#1681495)
That's true, but as you say UK students aren't necessarily that tied down. I moved (in the UK) from a physics undergrad to research in machine learning and statistics. This sort of move is common.
Re:PhD or Not PhD: that is the question
by arethuza on Saturday September 11, 2010 @09:37AM
(#1681541)
I'm pretty sure people in the UK used to say exactly the same thing about US PhDs!
Re:PhD or Not PhD: that is the question
by blacksmythe on Saturday September 11, 2010 @10:40AM
(#1681613)
True in my limited experience (EE not CS). The UK PhDs get a pretty well defined thesis topic and graduate on schedule.
The US PhDs don't have a clear finish line until less than a year from finishing.
The "joke" in the US is that if someone says they are six months from finishing it is really a year, if they say a year from finishing it is 2+ years, if they say more than a year they have no idea how much longer.