News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Infuriating Innocence of Mark Zuckerberg by Animats on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @01:09PM (#16813227)
The real problem is advertising. "You're not the customer, you're the product".

We've been here before. Back in the 1950s, when TV commercials appeared, the ad industry was portrayed as a villain. "Selling out to Madison Avenue" was considered a despicable act for a writer. There were books on the evils of ads - "The Hidden Persuaders" (Packard, 1957). The US Congress held hearings on the evils of television. TV did change the world. For the first time ever, ordinary people had more free entertainment coming in than they could consume. That had never happened before in all of history.

Facebook is a new technology for delivering ads. The problems come from being ad-supported, not the nature of a social network. If Facebook were a paid service without ads, most of the intrusiveness would go away.

What we need to regulate is advertising, not networking.

Re:The Infuriating Innocence of Mark Zuckerberg by cafard on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:21PM (#16813889)
In the 1950s, and much more recently, the ad industry had to make guesses, based on very limited data, about who was seeing what ads on broadcast media. Sure, the ads for auto batteries and tires ran with football games, not with soap operas. But compared to what you can do with on-line media, they were working in the dark.
Re:The Infuriating Innocence of Mark Zuckerberg by 18pfsmt on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @04:54PM (#16815531)
I’ve always liked your historical perspectives (often times controversial). I’m not really into regulations at all, but it’s not the advertising that is such an issue, it’s the surveillance required to accomplish ‘targeted advertising’ that’s more of the issue these days. Infomercials on broadcast TV are one thing, but actual tracking of your viewership is entirely different (connected to your home address/credit score/demographic specifics).

>...you're the product”

I know pithy sayings are popular right now, but HN should probably stay away from that sort of demagoguery. November 29, 2010 is the first time I can find that phrase being used on HN (in a Lifehacker post): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1952292

Re:The Infuriating Innocence of Mark Zuckerberg by lbearl on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @04:46PM (#16815414)
That's an interesting take. Facebook is basically Television 2.0, with all of the advantages (free entertainment) that come with inherent costs (advertising), and as was pointed out in a sibling, with TV the advertisers didn't have nearly as much information as they do now.

I wonder if the same parallels would be applicable to broadcast vs cable TV? Namely: ad supported (broadcast), versus subscriber supported with additional ads (cable). More broadly I wonder if that is a direction we'll see social networks start moving into, to date, I don't believe any pay-for social network has gotten any real traction.