Take Norway for example, it was said earlier that they officially run on only about 40% green energy. However in actual reality they run closer to 100% on green energy and everyone there knows it. Then a coal power factory somewhere can buy the Norwegian credits and claim to be 100% green and sell that. It's no wonder many people don't like this scheme.
But as you say and I agree, it is probably a net positive.
No this is not happening anywhere, where are you coming with this kind of things?
Coal company producing only coal-generated power don't buy green credits.
If 100GW renewal energy is produced, who or how it is being used is irrelevant, because the alternative would be 100GW energy generated through non-renewable resources. I don't in which version of reality is that a bad thing, regardless of who buys whatever REC credit.
This is a net positive whichever way you spin it. Pollution doesn't understand state or country boundaries.