Of course, they were right. I was out on my own again within 6 months:)
In both cases you do the same work but the first is not going to raise too many follow up questions.
As a rule though, those that have worked for start-ups and/or were founders will not normally go back to big-corp to do a 9 to 5, and in the age of google even if you don't disclose it you may be found out anyway.
Yes, that's illegal in plenty of places but it happens quite frequently regardless of that.
You'd be amazed how things change when you get into your 30's and start having kids. ;)
Yes, that's pretty much my situation, only you can add another decade.
(I want to be generous and think it's because in large companies the how-we-do-it-here knowledge has to be taught, so it's more valuable than the how-to-get-it-to-compile knowledge and they need long tenures)