News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stackoverflow is "some random website" by pjc50 on Monday April 09, 2018 @10:59AM (#16793496)
The problem with SO is simple:

- many of the questions would actually work better on a forum that was explicitly somewhat transient, rather than somewhere that tries to keep the best answers ""forever""

- there is no such forum

- Jeff Atwood wrote Discourse more-or-less as an attempt to build the right kind of forum software for that purpose. But there is still no such forum, or at least not one that SO questions can be moved to.

Re:Stackoverflow is "some random website" by jupp0r on Monday April 09, 2018 @11:33AM (#16793885)
Most of the time I read forums, it's because I want to get an overview over the latest discussion on a topic (most recently BBQ grills). Whenever I'm redirected to forums via a search engine, it's mostly "this has been asked before, use the search", rants, and other low quality content.

The incentives in the SO community lead to pretty good quality overall, compared to forums. Answers are regularly updated, even years afterwards. I've never seen that in forums.

Re:Stackoverflow is "some random website" by vbezhenar on Monday April 09, 2018 @11:02AM (#16793535)
Why do you think that forum is better than SO? I think that SO does its job pretty well: good questions (or answers) are visible, especially via Google while bad or non-interesting questions are vanished forever. Forum is about discussions. Most of programming questions are not about discussions, but rather simple question-answer style. And discussions are not welcome in SO anyway.
Re:Stackoverflow is "some random website" by pjc50 on Monday April 09, 2018 @11:08AM (#16793596)
> discussions are not welcome in SO anyway

Yes, so rather than deleting the question unanswered on a few people's subjective opinion that the question is a "discussion", move it to the forum?

(e.g. I ran into this problem https://stackoverflow.com/questions/49302369/gdpr-encrypted-... ; would you say that's a discussion? It got closed until I cheated by mentioning it on HN, resulting in helpful HN readers re-opening it)