That said, I think the California courts have gone too far in stripping employers of reasonable protections precisely in this area of "inevitable disclosure." To me, when I see someone as strategically placed as Mr. Hurd was in HP simply move over to a co-president role and board-level position, the prospects for misusing trade-secret information from his former employer are basically sky-high and, given the existing law, I see him cynically laughing at HP in spite of the serious risks his position poses to HP's trade secret information and in spite of the fantastic sum they paid to him for a graceful exit. In rejecting inevitable disclosure, the California courts have reasoned that this doctrine effectively converts a confidentiality obligation into a non-compete in circumstances where a departing employee is not even paid for the non-compete itself and therefore would violate the public policy against unreasonable restraints on trade. Based on this reasoning, the courts have categorically rejected the doctrine, i.e., declared it as invalid on its face, and have been unwilling to apply it to selective cases where the public policy concerns are not truly implicated (such as I believe this Hurd case is). This goes too far, in my view. One of the carve-out provisions for an enforceable non-compete under California law is precisely that of a case where the non-compete is needed to protect an employer's trade secret information. This is routinely applied in cases of those who are exposed to an employer's whole book of business, e.g., insurance brokers, and who could otherwise just copy the list and raid the client base via a targeted solicitation using confidential client information. It would not be a big stretch for the courts to say that the inevitable-disclosure rule could sometimes be applied in specific cases as a tool that is essential to protect trade secrets and hence within a permissible exception (or carve-out) to the ban on non-competes. If they were to do so, I would think it would be relatively easy to say that a case such as that of Mr. Hurd is one by which an effective non-compete provision is needed to protect the former employer's interests. As so interpreted, the inevitable-disclosure doctrine would fit within one of the established bases upon which a non-compete could be enforced and could be used to prevent abuses of the type that might be occurring here with Mr. Hurd. Nor would this violate the rationale advanced by the existing California cases (that such an interpretation would effectively enable an employer to impose a non-compete obligation on a former employer without paying for the privilege), since, as here, the employer sometimes pays in spades and should get the protection.
Thus, I don't have a problem with the general California law on this subject, nor with its public policy rationale, but I think the courts have misapplied that rationale to needlessly strip employers of protections for the type of case presented here. That same law, and that same rationale, could easily be applied to reach a more sensible outcome as long as the court decisions are not so doctrinaire about protecting former employees at all costs. A more sensible and balanced approach could easily be adopted without doing violence to the existing public policy. The flaw is not in the policy but in its application for this specific type of case.
Hope this helps.
Neither of these reasons seem to apply here. Hurd didn't have to agree to the exit package they offered. He could have simply quit like an ordinary worker quits--walked out the door with his last paycheck. The $33 million he got makes it so he has no need to "make a living" for the next two years.
The problem here, though, is that the $33 million was presumably paid in connection with a broad settlement by which the parties mutually would have release all legal claims against one another. There is no formal non-compete obligation here (as this would be unenforceable under California law). Of course, part of the settlement is that Mr. Hurd honor its confidentiality terms by which he cannot disclose or misuse HP's trade secrets. That commitment, however, is governed by the California law that protects the employer from threatened breaches of that obligation upon a proper showing of evidence but that does not enable a court to block the employee from taking a position with a competing company simply based on the notion that he would inevitably disclose such trade secret information by virtue of the position he holds with the competitor.
The California law applies whether or not the employee has the ability to ride out a non-compete period in terms of earning a living. It is codified in the state's statutes and judges cannot make an exception based on the fact that a particular employee got well-paid on his departure (especially since the payment was not in fact given in exchange for a non-compete but for other reasons).
The former is what I summarized above but the latter is what motivates a court to want to go one way or the other, as long as it can find a legal "hook" to go that way. As to this, it does matter that Mr. Hurd is head of a multi-billion dollar corporation and that he got a huge severance as part of leaving his employment. Given those facts, judges will be more motivated than otherwise to find a reason why he should be restricted in some fashion as part of his two-year confidentiality agreement. Thus, if the HP lawyers can come up with even a modicum of evidence to show "threatened" compromises of trade secrets, the court might go their way simply out of a sense of justice inspired by the background factors that are not technically relevant to the letter of the law.
So, yes, that factor can be relevant in the way just described.
By the way, this is why contingent lawyers never go into court with an "unattractive" plaintiff (meaning a "creep" and not physically unattractive) - even if you are technically right on the law, no judge or jury wants to out of their way to reward that which they regard as repulsive. This is always crucial to remember in assessing any case.
This case will turn on what is known as the "inevitable disclosure" doctrine, which has been explicitly rejected in California, going back to the Schlage Lock case in 2002 (see http://library.findlaw.com/2003/Mar/18/132641.html) and most recently in Flir Systems, where the court found that a trade secrets case had been brought in bad faith because it was based on inevitable disclosure. (A recent article on why this case law makes HP's Hurd case an uphill fight appears here: http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202471748471).
Basically, California law prohibits non-competes in a post-employment context unless coupled with a transfer of a goodwill interest (e.g., when your business is acquired) and, when an employer complains that a former employee will "inevitably" disclose valuable trade secret information by reason of his position with a new firm, the courts have rightly interpreted this position as an after-the-fact attempt by the employer to get what amounts to non-compete-style protection where the law otherwise forbids this.
At the same time, HP is not without arguments because California's adoption of the Uniform Trade Secrets Act does authorize courts to enjoin "threatened" violations of an employer's trade secrets. This usually means the employer has to present detailed evidence that the former employee's role in the new company poses a clear threat that this would happen. Of course, without additional evidence, the mere fact that the employee's new position poses such risks really amounts to "inevitable disclosure" (which the courts reject) and this means that a complaining party is not likely to win such a case unless it really does have some other evidence strongly suggesting that trade secrets are likely to be compromised. That is why it is such an uphill fight for the employer.
Inevitable disclosure cases are often upheld elsewhere in the U.S. but even then it most often happens when the departing executive is shown to have done suspicious things along the way (see, e.g., this piece summarizing why a guy who was one of a handful of people in the world to know the ingredients and processes by which Thomas' English muffins achieve their "nook and cranny" feel could legitimately be enjoined from joining a direct competitor, and where the evidence showed that he hung around for months after secretly accepting the competing employment and, in effect, gathered information from his old employer in anticipation of the move: http://chicagobreakingbusiness.com/2010/07/english-muffin-se...).
In my view of it, major egos are involved on both sides of this Hurd mess and that is likely what is driving this lawsuit. It will therefore be brutally fought and, if there is an ounce of anything in the law to support an injunction, HP will scrape for and find it. Given the well-settled California law, however, this effort is likely to amount only to a wild swing that is unlikely to land. This may mean that Mr. Hurd will get a windfall while HP is left with nothing but a black eye, but that is what is most likely to happen.