2. There are plenty of games that fly under the radar, and the press will give them one review to lament their failure and then a follow-up when the studio closes and there's a massive layoff. Stories about failing games don't get traffic like stories about popular, beloved games. This has only become more true with the onset of digital storefronts.
So if you don't look, you only see a stream of hit products.
> Make Builds and Test Them: Imagine a game has a 2-year development deadline. Imagine the first playtest happening 1 year and 9 months into development. This happens. Make regular builds of your game and playtest them, even starting from week one. If you are a serious game development company, you probably should have an automated build pipeline of some sort. Pro-tip: Automation is cheaper and more effective than human labor.
Large games like this are generally smarter today taking it to market with smaller teams and getting funding and alpha/beta feedback all along the way. Fortnite for instance has been in development with available builds for Epic using Unreal Engine 4 almost since inception and became a better game for prototyping/early and often releases.
[1] https://www.pcgamer.com/the-biggest-mmo-failures-in-history/
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/38_Studios
[3] https://allarsblog.com/2018/03/16/confessions-of-an-unreal-e...
I should have said Everquest (1999) as that one really started the craze leading to WoW.
But the WoW success is what led the insane MMO bubble/hype as it broke all types of records and everyone wanted to be the next World of Warcraft.
When I worked at Cheyenne Mountain on Stargate Worlds, part of the job was understanding WoW and playing WoW to level 70, then 80 on Wrath of the Lich King, our CEO had done it twice, everyone there played WoW because everyone wanted to replicate it.
Turns out WoW was an outlier not the norm or the future, but every game company wanted subscription money not one and done purchases and it led to tons of investment and hype.
Sony even couldn't replicate Everquest with Everquest 2, Planetside nor Starwars Galaxies, though I loved Planetside.
From last year, Agents of Mayhem was really in a league of it's own for AAA games. It had Steam sales numbers of ~20k a month after launch, so <100k across all the platforms combined. From the year before that the most high profile flops would probably be Battleborn or Evolve.
Some of those were axed early on in development, but I have personally worked on a game that was cancelled after spending at least $10M.
Publishers know when to cut their losses.
Then again Star Citizen probably has its day of reckoning coming.
A few recent released AAA flops: MoH:Warfighter, Sea of Thieves, Titanfall 1 (and 2?), Battleborn, For Honor, Prey, Lawbreakers, Paragon etc. etc.
A lot of bad publicity and public fights is not only way to fail, often simply nobody cares.
Both games have been heavily changed and built upon to make them fun and worth their price.
Where are all these failed products though? I can name Mass Effect: Andromeda and basically nothing else in recent years. Hollywood has far more big flops.
Big-budget games are almost guaranteed some degree of success. If you follow the proven formulas and don't mess up, the game sells.