News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by creaghpatr on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:47PM (#16777253)
Yup, people would like to spin this as the government cracking down on garden-variety prostitution, yet Backpage in particular has many dubious ties to child trafficking.
Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by chimeracoder on Friday April 06, 2018 @06:33PM (#16778085)
> Yup, people would like to spin this as the government cracking down on garden-variety prostitution, yet Backpage in particular has many dubious ties to child trafficking.

The law does criminalize any activity relates to prostitution, not sex trafficking. That's not spin - that's literally the express purpose of the law as written. It's not a coincidence that the law is written to apply to all forms of sex work.

Blumenthal, the senator who authored the bill, has been personally crusading against sex work from the past decade, longer than he's even been in the Senate. He chose Backpage as the particular target for this bill, but it's not like he hasn't gone after any and all forms of sex work in the past.

Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by gowld on Saturday April 07, 2018 @01:28AM (#16779510)
What are those ties? The article above only mentions "adult services" and sex work.
Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by dmix on Saturday April 07, 2018 @03:38AM (#16779808)
When users submitted listings with keywords like "young girls" (and worse) it would automatically detect them and suggest edits to allow the listing to still be posted without triggering any red flags. Among other things (?).

Which is why the feds believe they crossed the line into actively assisting criminal activity when they should have just been dissuading or outright blocking the people creating this type of content on the site.

Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by AFNobody on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:53PM (#16777332)
It isn't a spin because it has resulted in a crack down in garden variety prostitution and a shutdown of multiple services (including ones that were purely defensive exercises of free speech, such as unsafe/bad date lists).
Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by creaghpatr on Friday April 06, 2018 @05:04PM (#16777426)
I expect the coming allegations will detail conspiracy to commit a crime and/or RICO between the people running the site and sex traffickers.

The key thing that will need to be proven is the complicity of the admins, although if they are already seizing the site I expect the authorities have what a judge or grand jury feels is enough evidence to warrant the seizure.

Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by chimeracoder on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:04PM (#16778254)
> The key thing that will need to be proven is the complicity of the admins

No. That's what used to be necessary, before SESTA and FOSTA passed[0]. The whole point of SESTA and FOSTA was to remove that requirement - websites are now liable even if they aren't complicit. Even if they take active efforts to combat sex work on their service, they're still liable if someone manages to use the site for that purpose.

Again, none of this relates to sex trafficking. It applies to consensual sex work.

[0] And even though SESTA and FOSTA aren't signed into law yet, Blumenthal specifically wrote the law to apply retroactively. So once the bills are signed, this lower standard is what will apply.

Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by dragonwriter on Saturday April 07, 2018 @01:55AM (#16779571)
> The whole point of SESTA and FOSTA was to remove that requirement - websites are now liable even if they aren't complicit.

FOSTA has an intent to facilitate prostitution requirement, SESTA has a lower threshold with regard to trafficking.

> Again, none of this relates to sex trafficking. It applies to consensual sex work.

True of FOSTA, but not SESTA.

> And even though SESTA and FOSTA aren't signed into law yet, Blumenthal specifically wrote the law to apply retroactively.

At least as far as criminal liability goes, that is a fairly direct violation of the prohibition on ex post facto laws; for civil liabilities that would otherwise be barred by the Section 230 safe harbor, though, that's not an issue.

Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by joering2 on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:56PM (#16778539)
Then how come I don't see Zuckerberg and Sandberg behind bars yet?

Don't tell me there is none, or never been a sex trafficking thru Facebook.

Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by dragonwriter on Saturday April 07, 2018 @02:00AM (#16779579)
> Then how come I don't see Zuckerberg and Sandberg behind bars yet?

Well, because SESTA hasn't gone into effect yet. You can bet once it does there will be at least private civil cases against Facebook. Public, including criminal, ones might take until they've got precedent from smashing less well-funded defendants, but they'll come, too, especially (even if Facebook takes drastic action now to prevent future liability) for past cases under the retroactivity provisions (which should be constitutionally problematic for criminal cases, but not so much for civil cases.)

Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by 220V_USKettle on Friday April 06, 2018 @08:16PM (#16778628)
There is no ticker symbol for backpage in their portfolio.
Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by nym on Friday April 06, 2018 @08:13PM (#16778609)
Laws like this are selective in nature.
Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by PrimHelios on Friday April 06, 2018 @08:10PM (#16778595)
That one's simple: bribery.
Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by AFNobody on Friday April 06, 2018 @05:21PM (#16777568)
The problem is, they passed a bunch of legal changes recently under the guise of "Well, it is because Backpage cannot be brought to Justice."

And now, well, "Oh yeah we had the power all along" which is what your comment is stating as your belief.

That is why your claims about spin are problematic to me. You are ignoring the background of the situation to make a very narrow claim about "spin" when the claims of "spin" are about the laws they passed citing Backpage.

Re:Backpage.com seized by U.S. justice authorities by creaghpatr on Friday April 06, 2018 @06:56PM (#16778206)
SESTA has not been signed into law so I’m not sure what you’re talking about, unless the sex workers were on the Backpage payroll.