News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by coldtea on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:13PM (#16775015)
The world is not driven by economics (and its simplistic assumptions), it's driven by power relations and human nature.

Supply and demand is not the only thing to influence the job market -- power and knowledge asymmetries can do the same thing just as well.

Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by andrewla on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:35PM (#16775271)
I think this is getting into map vs. territory issues. This is certainly the domain of economics -- the particular simplifying model used by many economists does not appear to paint a complete picture.

By analogy, adapting a James Morrow quote: "Economics does have all the answers. The problem is that we don’t have all the economics".

Power and knowledge asymmetries are well within the domain that economics tries to encompass.

Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by iovrthoughtthis on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:40PM (#16775339)
Great use of map vs territory.
Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by maxxxxx on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:27PM (#16775176)
Exactly. Economics is not natural law but it operates in a framework that's completely human made. This framework is defined by moral values, practicality, whoever is in power and a lot of other factors.

We could easily have an economy where we just accept that nobody can own land or it's OK to take things by force. then economists would build their models around that framework.

Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by Florin_Andrei on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:26PM (#16775169)
Well, it's driven by the laws of this universe, ultimately. At the level of inanimate matter, that's thermodynamics and such. At our level, it's meta stuff like evolutionary processes.

There's power in there, for sure. There's instinct and emotion, too. There's thinking and reason also. It's an all of the above type of thing. But we tend to stick to the things that are most obvious to us individually.

The universe is a giant computer on a path to compute some kind of humongous outcome. We're just execution units carrying out subroutines. We may or may not have some freedom locally (that's another debate).

Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by gowld on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:24PM (#16775131)
What is the difference between economics and power relations?

Human nature I understand -- people have mental/emotional shortcuts that are not precise and accurate rational analysis.

Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by coldtea on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:30PM (#16775212)
>What is the difference between economics and power relations?

In an ideal world, economics would study power relations as they relate to money -- that's what the old economists (19th century and so) called "political economy".

In the present world, economics are a shallow ideology around the "free market", with naive abstractions and axioms. Usually these are mostly peddled by the media and "popularizer" economists at the masses, but what actual academic economists sell is not that much better.

Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by dragonwriter on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:43PM (#16775378)
> In an ideal world, economics would study power relations as they relate to money -- that's what the old economists (19th century and so) called "political economy".

“Money” is overly restrictive, it's really all goods and services, and the old “political economy” is a substantial part of what eventually became the field of “political science”. It may not still be considered mainly in the scope of Economics departments, but then what used to be called “natural philosophy, while still studied, isn't part of scope of the Philosophy department.

Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by anubisresources on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:46PM (#16775408)
What economics courses have you taken that are remotely like this? Economics is extremely quantitative and is not some “shallow ideology”.
Re:Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed... by coldtea on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:37PM (#16777173)
It's "extremely quantitative" non-predictions premised upon a shallow ideology.