News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German Military Study Warns of Drastic Oil Crisis by acqq on Thursday September 09, 2010 @08:11PM (#1677420)
Estimate errors are not important -- the certainty that the peak comes however is!

Try to think about it, you know how exponents of 2 work:

1

2

(...)

1024

2048

Now note that to move from point n to the point n + 1 you need to use as much as in all points from 1 to n - 1: when you're at point of 1024, to move to the point of 2048 (double) you'll need 1+2+4+8+...+512 + 1 of something.

According to

http://www.pbs.org/frontlineworld/stories/colombia/oila.html

the doubling time of world oil consumption is 30 years (just as little as 2.3% usage growth per year makes that!) That means that during the next 30 years the world needs as much oil as the total oil used from the beginning of the oil use to the 1980(!) Think again about that simple fact!

Now if you know that all oil in the Earth formed from the preserved remains of prehistoric zooplankton and algae, which had settled to a sea or lake bottom in large quantities under anoxic conditions, you can imagine that the supply is really limited.

Re:German Military Study Warns of Drastic Oil Crisis by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @08:22PM (#1677447)
Coal can be converted to oil. At present prices this is not economical. But when the oil price goes up above the point where it is economical suddenly the 'reserves' will have to include all the coal reserves.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fischer%E2%80%93Tropsch_process

That would (iirc, can't find a quick and reasonably reliable source) double the total available oil for the next 50 years or so, and then there are currently uneconomical sources such as tar sands.

So, in short, yes, it will run out and fairly soon but not as soon as you might think based on just the oil reserves.

Re:German Military Study Warns of Drastic Oil Crisis by acqq on Thursday September 09, 2010 @08:27PM (#1677456)
Note that even the doubling the estimated world reserves that you suggest gives the humanity only a few decades more. Where do you get 50 years when the current estimated doubling time of consumption is 30 years?

Approximately 40% of the world electricity production uses coal as we speak. It's not that the coal is just waiting to be used instead of oil.

Your kids (if you have them) will experience oil problems anyway! Not to mention the effects of all that CO2 in the atmosphere.

Re:German Military Study Warns of Drastic Oil Crisis by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @08:43PM (#1677484)
> Note that even the doubling the estimated world reserves that you suggest gives the humanity only a few decades more.

Yep.

> Where do you get 50 years when the current estimated doubling time of consumption is 30 years?

From the combined effect of coal to oil conversion (for transportation), increased reliance on alternative energy, a rising oil price eventually causing both reduced consumption and at the same time making currently un-economical sources economical.

> Approximately 40% of the world electricity production uses coal as we speak.

That's correct.

> It's not that the coal is just waiting to be used instead of oil.

That's true as well, but we do have more and more alternative sources for energy production other than coal. That it's only 40% is actually quite amazing. Natural gas is another big source of electricity, nuclear is another.

> Your kids (if you have them) will experience oil problems anyway!

I do, and most likely.

> Not to mention the effects of all that CO2 in the atmosphere.

The magnitude of those effects is still up for debate. I'm very much concerned about the dent the whole CO2 story got from the scandal around the leaked climate documents.

The people around me that were 'mildly skeptical' are now in the 'no way' camp and those that believed the facts as they were presented up to then are now openly skeptical.

There are still many people who are convinced the CO2 emissions are bad and that the greenhouse effect is going to have an impact on their lives but there definitely has been a sea-change in attitude.

Re:German Military Study Warns of Drastic Oil Crisis by ams6110 on Thursday September 09, 2010 @08:45PM (#1677487)
Agree. Think about life 100 years ago. Sometimes I just sit in wonder at what human civilization has accomplished since the start of the 20th century, compared to all of human history before then.

I think it's pretty likely that sometime in the next few decades we'll have a replacement for oil. It may very well be technology that hasn't been discovered yet. But I see no reason to think that we'll just use up all the oil and have no alternatives.

Re:German Military Study Warns of Drastic Oil Crisis by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:02PM (#1677520)
I think we agree less than you think :)

We won't come up with some magic replacement for oil, unless ITER is successful, and we manage to adapt the fusion principle to a scale small enough for transportation use, but that's not something I would bet on at this stage.

More likely we'll see incremental change together with market forces reshape our society in a way that we can currently not predict.

My best guess would be more nuclear (pebble bed?), more solar, more wind, more oil from weird places and much more conservation efforts driven by prices that you can (probably) not imagine today.

In Europe a Gallon of gasoline sells for ~$6 today, imagine what would happen to the US if it had a gas prices that high.

Re:German Military Study Warns of Drastic Oil Crisis by laut on Friday September 10, 2010 @01:36AM (#1677996)
Yeah, there are technical alternatives already, but it's a question of econonmics.

If there is less oil produced prices will rise and less will be consumed. There are many alternatives, but today oil is just cheap enough for many uses.

Natural gas is one alternative, that can be used instead of oil to fuel cars and for heating. There is plenty of that around. If the price of oil rises a lot more than natural gas, more people will run cars on natural gas.

Electrical cars and wood gas are other technologies that have been around for a long time, but just aren't quite as practical. But if oil becomes a lot more expensive, the alternatives will start to look better in comparison.

Re:German Military Study Warns of Drastic Oil Crisis by pyre on Thursday September 09, 2010 @08:57PM (#1677513)
It's nice to be optimistic, but we can't just assume that all of the problems we have today will be fixed be some 'mircale' technology tomorrow, so there is no need or drive to fix them now.