Re:SICP - summary of 10 months working through the entire book
by carterschonwald on Friday April 18, 2008 @07:29PM
(#167736)
Don't Use Dummit and Foote! Use Artin or something like Hungerford or MacClane!
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:SICP - summary of 10 months working through the entire book
by cia_plant on Friday April 18, 2008 @09:31PM
(#167785)
I found Artin to be overly wordy and often imprecise. I found Hungerford to be extremely dry and boring, but admittedly I only got through a short part of it.
Lang is very good, IMO, but more difficult.
Re:SICP - summary of 10 months working through the entire book
by carterschonwald on Saturday April 19, 2008 @06:21PM
(#168169)
my experience was that Hungerford's presentation was organized, concise, and its great how he is explicit in differentiating between a proof and a proof sketch.
I'd hesitate to suggest to any of Lang's writings as the first go on a technical topic. If you are already comfortable with the material, his writings will give new insight and intuitions, but thats different from a first go at understanding a topic
(note to audience, we're talking about different math textbooks)