News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by cyphar on Friday April 06, 2018 @05:49AM (#16772072)
I'm wondering whether the intention with these sorts of blog posts (GitHub has done several of these in the past[1,2], where they provide a summary of the release notes) is to try to put in people's minds the link that "git" == "GitHub". To be fair, the author is actually the 2nd largest contributor (by commits) to the git project. Just thought it was a bit strange.

[1]: https://blog.github.com/2016-11-29-git-2-11-has-been-release... [2]: https://blog.github.com/2017-05-10-git-2-13-has-been-release...

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by jcl on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:48AM (#16772474)
I don't know... While the title might give that impression, the opening paragraph seems pretty up-front about distinguishing "the open source Git project" from GitHub ("here's our look..."). They don't even mention their not-insignificant contributions to the project, nor do they say things like "we added [x]", even though they legitimately might be able to in some cases.

And, given their line of work, it would be kind of surprising if the GitHub blog didn't cover recent Git developments.

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by paradite on Friday April 06, 2018 @09:18AM (#16772944)
Out of curiosity, would you be surprised by:

- Git 2.17 is now available (gitlab.com)

- Git 2.17 is now available (bitbucket.com)

The point is, by publishing this kind of posts, Github is making you associate git with Github. Anecdote example: my university lecturer calls Github APIs "git APIs". While that might not be a bad thing, it blurs the boundary between an open source project and a company.

I can already imagine Github having influence on the direction of git project and becomes the de facto owner, and the impact on its competitors and the repository hosting industry. The equivalence would be Microsoft, instead of owning TypeScript, owns the ECMAScript specification.

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by sytse on Friday April 06, 2018 @10:44AM (#16773584)
I think GitHub has done a great job being a good steward of the git project. They welcomed us (GitLab) to events like git merge. Because they made git popular people are sometimes confused about the difference between git and GitHub. But GitHub has done a great job on not muddling the water themselves.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by paradite on Friday April 06, 2018 @10:54AM (#16773670)
Okay. I guess if you say so then I was just being paranoid and overreacting.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by sytse on Friday April 06, 2018 @10:59AM (#16773724)
I'm not saying that, just giving our point of view. BTW I still meet a lot of people that think GitHub is open source instead of them hosting open source.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by Nadya on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:33PM (#16774560)
Which was one of the top 3 reasons I chose to host my projects on GitLab instead of GitHub. Thank you for supporting OSS by being OSS yourself!
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by sytse on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:06PM (#16775676)
You're welcome. Thanks for using GitLab. BTW We refer to ourselves as an open core company since we also sell proprietary features.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by coldtea on Friday April 06, 2018 @10:11AM (#16773340)
>Out of curiosity, would you be surprised by

No, not at all.

>The point is, by publishing this kind of posts, Github is making you associate git with Github

Well, git IS associated with GitHub. It's the de facto #1 hosting service for Git repositories, eclipsing all others, and the #1 host of open source git repos. They're also major contributors to Git.

But regardless of all that, they host git repos. They literally work with people that use Git, day in, day out, and help them host their git managed code.

Of course they'll cover developments in Git. Who else would be more natural to cover them (aside something like "Git planet")? The GTK+ blog? The IEEE?

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by peff on Friday April 06, 2018 @11:23AM (#16773923)
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by jcl on Monday April 09, 2018 @05:33PM (#16797195)
FWIW, I'd expect any git hosting provider -- including gitlab.com and bitbucket.com -- to be similarly eager to evangelize new git releases, since an improvement to git is an improvement to the usability of their offerings. At the very least, encouraging users to upgrade to easier-to-use git versions could reduce support costs and customer churn.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by Karlozkiller on Friday April 06, 2018 @11:07AM (#16773790)
I've had colleagues believe bitbucket is a replacement for git.

I had to explain there's a quite big difference between the two. I assume he had mixed up github with git and correctly deduced bitbucket is an alternative to github.

Also, I got way too excited over the git news to notice that it was github publishing ...

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by peff on Friday April 06, 2018 @11:20AM (#16773889)
Thanks for the feedback in this thread (I'm the author). The main goal _is_ to let people know about the new version, and about new features they can use (there are a ton of other new features and a lot of backend speedups and cleanups that I don't bother to highlight, because they're not really actionable by normal users).

I've tried to make the Git vs GitHub distinction clear in the first paragraph without belaboring it, but I agree with the sentiment here that the title muddies things. For future iterations I'll look into something more like "A look at the new features in v2.17".

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by daveFNbuck on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:13PM (#16774371)
I think the title you used is a lot less confusing than "A look at the new features in v2.17". A title like that doesn't mention Git would make me think that GitHub is releasing v2.17 if its own product. I don't think there's a way you can clear this up within the title.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by peff on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:52PM (#16777323)
Er, sorry, I meant to say "...the new features in Git v2.17".

I think that keeps it clear but without making it overtly look like a release announcement.

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by daveFNbuck on Saturday April 07, 2018 @01:09AM (#16779467)
Ok, I think that does actually make things a bit more clear. Thanks for writing these up, by the way!
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by sametmax on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:29AM (#16772404)
It's a sane marketing strategy, let's not blame them for this.

They are, after all, a major actor of the git ecosystem, with a great track record, using quality blog posts to inform your of their main tech.

I see zero problem with this.

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by mkirklions on Friday April 06, 2018 @10:03AM (#16773277)
I run a few websites, and you bet that each of them will give shutouts to each other.

They are all free, they all help users.

git and github has helped me, and ive never paid. I consider all of this fantastic.

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by golergka on Friday April 06, 2018 @09:18AM (#16772942)
Writing genuinely informative articles about your company's area of competence is a very widespread marketing approach. Just earlier today I've read a brief overview on moment theater written by some theater's marketing team. They didn't try to hide that it's a material designed to sell their tickets, but it didn't make it any less interesting.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by scarface74 on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:51AM (#16772484)
Open source developers have to eat too. I think it's a win-win. GitHub makes money by leveraging open source and they pay their employees to contribute to Git that benefits everyone.
Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by abhishekjha on Saturday April 07, 2018 @02:45AM (#16779681)
I had raised this issue of demarcation a few days back [0].

As a newcomer to git a few years back I wasn't able to tell if github is a part of git or not OR can you work with git without a github account. It was confusing to me as github allows some of the exact functionalities offered by git.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16600666

Re:New features from the last few versions of Git by jolmg on Friday April 06, 2018 @11:37AM (#16774037)
It does happen. When we were hiring a couple years back, some candidates seemed to be confusing the two or thought that git was a product of GitHub.