News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by confounded on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:55AM (#16771431)
I agree with your skepticism regarding people who express a lot of certainty about what will work, and what will happen in extreme and untested circumstances.

However, I strongly disagree that principles and morality aren’t essential. This is because when figuring out, as you say, ‘what works best’, there is no single definition of ‘best’. In fact, as a general rule, there’s thousands of competing ones. Principles are how you do a reasonable job of making consistent decisions towards meaningful change.

In addition to a system working well, it also needs to be understood to be working well by the people that live in it. If some definition of a ‘best’ metric was delivered by a Kafkaesque convoluted system that people found confusing, one which works well-enough on simple principles might be preferable.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by lifeformed on Friday April 06, 2018 @06:42AM (#16772238)
I agree. I didn't mean to imply that principles aren't important - surely there must be some metric to judge progress against. Principles should hold in a generalized, zoomed-out view of a society. But in practice, there are numerous exceptions and edge cases. Like, "maximize freedom" is generally a good rule but not always.

I feel like the principles we come up with are just rough approximations of what we intuitively know but can't elegantly express. The true moral principle for society is probably a monstrous concatenation of if-else statements. If the zoom-out view of society still follows the principles, then I think that ought to be sufficient for its citizens' concerns about the society's effectiveness and direction.