Re:The secret life of NaN
by scrupulusalbion on Thursday April 05, 2018 @04:57PM
(#16768724)
Can arithmetic be applyied to NaN a la i? (e.g. 5 + 2 * NaN = 5 + 2NaN)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
NaN is sort of viral. Any math operator (afaik) returns NaN if any of the operands is NaN. That means `5 + (2 * NaN)` becomes `5 + NaN`, which just becomes `NaN`.
Still, `5 + 2 * NaN == 5 + 2 * NaN` would return false, because it becomes `NaN == NaN`, and NaN is not equal to NaN.
Re:The secret life of NaN
by logicallee on Thursday April 05, 2018 @08:28PM
(#16770032)
what about 0 * instead of 2 * ? On one hand by the viral property it would seem to also be unequal? On the other hand having zero NaN is something every equation already has :D it seems fair to silently remove a 0 * NaN term.
It's not fair to remove 0 * NaN.
NaN will come up when doing
Inf - Inf
But clearly: 0 * (Inf - Inf)
cannot be said to be zero.NaN really is not a number.
IIRC, but I don't have the IEEE spec in front of me, any operation, binary or unary, that has an operand of NaN shall have the result of NaN.
"0 * NaN" makes as much sense as "0 * Blue". It's NaN because you're trying to do something that is fundamentally not multiplication.
Re:The secret life of NaN
by logicallee on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:24AM
(#16772380)
thanks - makes sense and is a clear explanation.