News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by jjeaff on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:20PM (#16766851)
But how in the world are you going to manage without ecc memory? You might have a bit get flipped by a cosmic ray once every 5 years of 24x7 computing.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by cullenking on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:46PM (#16767132)
Switched to a threadripper 1950 and used ecc memory and an nvme drive. Fastest computer I could build at the moment, cost less than half of a worse Mac,even with a 34 inch curved widescreen. Plus I got to go back to awesomewm. Finally I don't hate my dev environment. Feels good to get back to my pre-2013 roots.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by tnorgaard on Thursday April 05, 2018 @03:58PM (#16768357)
According to this IBM study [2]/Wiki article [0], the probability is much higher - per the study with 128GiB of memory it is every 1h 25min.

There was an anecdote[1] about a Power Mac cluster at a university, which basically couldn't get past boot because the memory errors was so frequent.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_ray#Effect_on_electroni... [1] https://spectrum.ieee.org/computing/hardware/how-to-kill-a-s... [2] http://www.pld.ttu.ee/IAF0030/curtis.pdf

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by protomyth on Thursday April 05, 2018 @02:50PM (#16767835)
An article of frequency of errors http://lambda-diode.com/opinion/ecc-memory-2
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by jjeaff on Thursday April 05, 2018 @03:15PM (#16768046)
There are plenty of papers that put the error frequency orders of magnitude lower than.

But even if true, so what? What are you doing on a workstation where a bit flipped every 3 days is going to cause a problem? Anything critical is going to have a software check. I just have never seen any legitimate argument for needing it in a workstation.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by protomyth on Thursday April 05, 2018 @03:35PM (#16768202)
> What are you doing on a workstation where a bit flipped every 3 days is going to cause a problem?

Depends what bit flips. Given some of the file formats out there, the bit flip just before it is written to the disc might be fatal.

> Anything critical is going to have a software check.

I would love to see someone go through github and analyze if that is true.

I just cannot imagine why it would be acceptable to have bit errors when a preventative measure is available. If the industry would stop looking at it as a value add, the cost would come down and we all would benefit from a more stable platform.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by jjeaff on Thursday April 05, 2018 @04:05PM (#16768403)
>we all would benefit from a more stable platform.

What instability are you talking about? Has anyone experience any instability ever on a workstation that could have been attributed to a cosmic ray bit flip?

I wouldn't trade a 10% memory performance drag for ECC if the memory was cheaper than standard.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by protomyth on Thursday April 05, 2018 @04:21PM (#16768505)
> What instability are you talking about?

By definition, if the bits can flip in a way that wasn't intended then it is not stable. I'll take the 10% because I pretty sure getting to wrong 10% faster is not worth it to me.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by com2kid on Thursday April 05, 2018 @03:24PM (#16768110)
Having worked on system where we had a crc on almost all data structures, let me tell you that bit flips happen more often then you want to know.

Not everyone crcs 100% of their structs.

If they don't, data is being slowly corrupted.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by jjeaff on Thursday April 05, 2018 @04:17PM (#16768476)
How do you know they were bit flips? And if they were, how do you know they were soft errors that could have been corrected with ecc and not hard errors that would have happened either way?
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by com2kid on Sunday April 08, 2018 @02:58AM (#16784995)
Because we had insanely good crash reporting and we root caused every crash report we got in that had more than half a dozen hits in the wild.

Hardware was at fault. Turns out suppliers push the truth a bit here and there about their chips, what is supposed to be an identical part # isn't always identical, parts from different manufacturers that are supposed to be interchangeable aren't, and technical manuals aren't always the best.

We had (what we thought was) rigorous memory testing in place at the factory, but under certain extreme conditions there was a 100% reproducible flip of a few bits in RAM. It was almost always the same bits, thankfully, that made it possible to track down!

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by gruez on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:24PM (#16766893)
intel xeon e3 or amd