News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by zeteo on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:49PM (#1676661)
Look, as much as I may disagree with Terry Jones, the only direct victim of his "hate speech" will be an inanimate object. If he was planning to burn, say, 200 copies of "The Audacity of Hope", there would be hardly any reaction to it. Burning a book does not kill troops and civilians overseas; suicidal fanatics, easily incensed by the smallest details of what Western democracy allows, do.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by pstuart on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:58PM (#1676696)
Try burning bibles and/or American flags down there and see how that goes.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by _delirium on Thursday September 09, 2010 @04:26PM (#1676803)
People do actually burn American flags on a semi-regular basis, don't they? I've heard of some court cases stemming from it (which the flag-burners have generally won), but no violence, at least not in the past few decades.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by MichaelSalib on Thursday September 09, 2010 @04:29PM (#1676816)
Given that some groups of Muslims have had their places of worship firebombed for the terrible crime of worshiping while Muslim, I have great confidence that if Muslims ever got together in the US for a flag or Bible burning, they would face retaliatory violence.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by oiuygtfrtghyju on Thursday September 09, 2010 @07:09PM (#1677280)
Yes the worst 'offenders' are the Boy Scouts, Army, Veterans associations and Fire Depts.

See USCODE Section 175(k), Chapter 1, Title 4

Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by zeteo on Thursday September 09, 2010 @04:04PM (#1676730)
Right, so is the main problem with the burning act itself, or with the reaction to it?
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by pyre on Thursday September 09, 2010 @04:30PM (#1676818)
When you are performing an act that you know will cause a certain reaction you are either: 1) trying to make a statement or 2) intentionally trying to cause that reaction.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by ladeniran on Thursday September 09, 2010 @05:20PM (#1676974)
Whatever consequence is direct in this case does not eliminate the logical reasoning that provoking the Muslims would have its effects on troops and civilians serving in Muslim communities around the world.

Terry Jones probably doesn't see this 'DIRECTLY' but if the burning ceremony does happen, I bet it will become the headline speech for radical clerks and recruiters for Al Qaeda and the Taliban for months maybe years to come. We forget that not all non-militants in these areas like the United States...many only seek a more valid reason to join the cause.

It amazes me that this guy who preaches peace and the 10 commandments does not think his actions could lead to the deaths of Christians one way or another. I don't go as far as saying "burning a book does kill troops and civilians overseas" but the indirect result of this action is probably the same.

This is free publicity for radicalists, an event that would be preached as prove America is an enemy of the muslim world and their actions in the middle east are unsincere and what not.

Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by _delirium on Thursday September 09, 2010 @05:24PM (#1676989)
I think that's probably true, but I'm wary of this line of arguments. For example, anti-Vietnam-war protestors were accused of endangering American troops by emboldening the Viet-Cong, and the journalists who published the Abu Ghraib photographs were accused of inflaming Muslim opinion by doing so, some commentators even going so far as to say that the decision to publish the photographs meant they had blood on their hands.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by hugh3 on Thursday September 09, 2010 @05:44PM (#1677057)
And that's all probably true. Anti-Vietnam-war protesters did endanger US troops and South Vietnamese civilians by emboldening the Viet Cong, and do in fact bear a great deal of responsibility for the fact that the war was eventually lost. The folks who chose to publish the Abu Ghraib photos and make a huge deal out of an incident of prisoner abuse no worse than what probably goes on a dozen times a year in any US civilian prison, likewise bear some responsibility for the provocation there.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by scott_s on Thursday September 09, 2010 @06:05PM (#1677126)
Saying that antiwar protestors bear responsibility that the war was lost assumes that the war was winnable.
Re:Website pulled on US church that wants to burn Korans [by... by scott_s on Thursday September 09, 2010 @06:08PM (#1677133)
I'm wary of it as well. But war protestors are protesting against US policy; the purpose of exposing abuse is to prevent it from occurring again. As far as I can tell, the Florida group are protesting the existence of Muslims. All are legally protected, but I'm comfortable drawing distinctions for myself for how I treat them.