News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:35PM (#16766416)
? Isn’t that a MacBook Pro?
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by jdietrich on Thursday April 05, 2018 @02:11PM (#16767410)
By comparison with high-end mobile workstations, it's a toy.

A maxed out Macbook Pro has 16GB of non-upgradeable, non-ECC RAM and a GPU with 4GB of vRAM and a Passmark score of 3,553.

Lenovo will sell me a machine with 64GB of socketed ECC RAM and a Quadro P5000 with 16GB of vRAM and a Passmark score of 10,281.

The Macbook Pro doesn't have built-in LTE. It has a non-removable battery. It throttles badly under sustained loads. It has chronic issues with display calibration. If you want a useful selection of ports, you'll need a bag full of fragile and easy to lose dongles. They've only just rolled out eGPU support and there's still no official support for Nvidia GPUs. There's no 17" option. It has that damnable butterfly keyboard.

Yes, the Macbook Pro is very thin and lightweight, but Apple have made a lot of performance and usability tradeoffs to get there. That doesn't sound very "pro" to me.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Thursday April 05, 2018 @05:07PM (#16768780)
I don’t get it.

Apple doesn’t make a mobile workstation. They make a Pro version of the MacBook.

Take a MacBook, give it some more power, and you mostly have a MacBook Pro.

If the complaint is why doesn’t Apple make a high-end mobile workstation I'm guessing because the market isn’t there for it? At least not at the scale for Apple to touch it?

A lot of professionals end up being serviced just fine by a “Pro MacBook”. I don’t get this obsession with acting like Apple is doing something wrong by making the MacBook Pro a pro version of the MacBook instead of something like a Dell Precision, they’re two very different things with two very different markets.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by jonhendry18 on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:26AM (#16771559)
There used to be a 17" MacBook Pro. Last one came out in 2009. It was a bit of a beast to carry around, but not prohibitively so. It was .98 inches thick and weighed 6.6 pounds. The current 15" MacBook Pro is .61 inches and weighs 4.02 pounds. So not a huge difference. I commuted on the bus and subway with a 17" pro with only minor discomfort.

It had gigabit ethernet, FW800, three USB ports, 1 thunderbolt port, ExpressCard/34 slot, audio in, audio out.

With the exact same form factor and updated ports, Apple could offer a hell of a Pro Macbook Pro. Just give it a 4k screen and an option for a second SSD in the space formerly used by a DVD drive.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by ethagknight on Thursday April 05, 2018 @06:37PM (#16769403)
While I agree with you, I spec'd out the Lenovo that the above commenter was referencing costs $5500 with all the "discounts" tossed in. MacBook Pro tops out at $3000 (without going crazy on SSD). I understand that the market for people wanting to spend over $3k on a laptop may be thin, it seems quite easy to just give someone the option to spend $5k on a Macbook Pro if they just have to have it. Why exclude the option?
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:30AM (#16770886)
Form factor? Could a MBP in its current form factor actually fit all that?
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by IOT_Apprentice on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:31AM (#16771345)
The form factor is one of the issues with the current design. Or simply add a third product line: MacBook Workstation. Thicker for a larger battery, cooling and higher end CPU/GPU and moar RAM. Xeon class processors as an option.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by jdietrich on Thursday April 05, 2018 @06:28PM (#16769342)
OSX is a closed platform. If you're an FCPX or Logic Pro user, you're totally reliant on Apple's hardware offerings. If Apple don't sell the hardware that you need to do your job, then you have the choice between switching over completely to Windows (not a straightforward task) or tolerating the least-worst option from Apple's lineup.

If Apple honestly say "we couldn't care less about professional users, we're making money hand over fist anyway", then at least we all know where we stand. Apple haven't taken that approach - they keep making grand overtures about how much they care about professional users. They keep making grand promises about how the perfect professional machine is just around the corner, how they're not updating the current machine because the next big thing is so incredible, amazing, awesome.

There are a lot of very loyal Mac users who have kept Apple in business through thick and thin, but their patience has been tested to breaking point. Those users have been a key part of Apple's marketing; Apple make computers for dreamers, visionaries, artists, the cultural elite.

I don't know anyone who is genuinely happy about being a Mac user, but I know a lot of people who grimly tolerate giving Apple their money. They know what to expect from next year's Macs - they'll be thinner, lighter and subtly worse in a lot of important ways.

What happens to the Mac brand if those users leave? What happens if the resentment felt towards Apple by photographers, video editors, 3D artists and recording engineers turns into a full-scale revolt? What happens if owning a Mac marks you out not as a sophisticated member of the cultural elite, but a nerd who wants a slick *nix experience or a sucker who paid $2000 for a Facebook machine?

Apple are playing a dangerous game. Apple don't need to care at the moment because the iPhone is so gratuitously profitable, but they should know better than anyone that the market is incredibly fickle. They're burning decades of goodwill for no obvious reason.

It wouldn't be particularly expensive to make the majority of pro users happy. Bring back the old cheesegrater Mac Pro and stuff it with the latest commodity components. Bring back a previous-generation MBP chassis and fill the extra space with an i9 or a Xeon E3, four SODIMM slots and a GTX 1070 Max Q or a Quadro P5000.

They don't have to promote these machines, they don't have to display them in Apple stores if they're ashamed of making a functional computer, they just need to make them and promise to keep making them to secure the continued loyalty of their most loyal customers. Apple won't do it, for reasons known only to them. In the long term, that could prove to be a very expensive oversight.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by JimmyAustin on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:32PM (#16770263)
Honestly they should consider bringing back the clone program. HP/Dell can sell me a workstation that runs OSX, that they update on their schedule, and I'll be happy. I don't want it pretty, I just want it functional.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by torstenvl on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:37PM (#16766442)
You mean the one without a real keyboard or the one with only one port while plugged in?
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:45PM (#16766515)
I disliked my new MBP at first honestly it’s not that bad if you can bring the rest of your hardware up to speed.

My monitor does video, charging, and USB 3 with full size ports with one cable.

And the keyboard is subjective, I got used to it pretty easily. I actually feel like it’s more tactile than the old one

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by nieksand on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:53PM (#16766596)
"it’s not that bad"

That is not the most ringing endorsement for a very expensive and supposedly premium laptop.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by majewsky on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:41PM (#16767072)
> My monitor does video, charging, and USB 3 with full size ports with one cable.

My Lenovo X1 Yoga also does everything via one Thunderbolt cable, but it also has a full selection of normal ports on the notebook itself rather than only on the docking station. It also has a 1440p touch screen and a nice keyboard, and still costs 1000 € less than a Macbook Pro ^W Deluxe.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Thursday April 05, 2018 @05:10PM (#16768795)
Ok. When I can walk into a Lenovo store and walk out with a loaner while mine gets fixed I’ll buy it. I’d also like OS X, but I can settle for Windows these days.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by lozf on Thursday April 05, 2018 @10:55PM (#16770568)
Lenovo has 3 years next business day on site service included with many models - you can choose to add the accidental damage option and it still costs less than AppleCare, not to mention options to upgrade to 4 or 5 years cover.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:26AM (#16770867)
I just searched and couldn’t actually find any models listed with it available, but even so the search I did came up with more results for “they couldn’t fix it onsite” than anything.

I’d rather pay the difference in AppleCare. Most developers on this site are making large sums of money with their machines, 1000$ or even 2000$ is hardly going to make a measurable difference on the ROI of my laptop.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by lozf on Friday April 06, 2018 @08:37AM (#16772706)
Let's hope Apple release an MBP that you like better then.

If the $2k isn't that significant, and minimal downtime is so important; may as well keep a slightly older refurb model on-site as a hot-spare ready to go just in case there's a problem... A policy that would work, whatever your OS / brand preference.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Friday April 06, 2018 @11:23AM (#16773921)
I love my MBP, I replied to the comment about my endorsement but for some reason the comment doesn’t show up if I’m logged out?

The endorsement was tempered by the fact that around these parts endorsing the new MBP is apparently treason. I’m getting my comments downvoted for implying the MacBook Pro is a fine machine.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by skellera on Thursday April 05, 2018 @06:55PM (#16769522)
They give loaner Macbook Pros?
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:28AM (#16770878)
If you setup Joint Venture at purchase. If you make a living off your Mac I’d recommend it because for one 500$ fee you can cover multiple devices
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by oldcynic on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:20PM (#16766847)
I tried to live with mine for about 6 months before giving up, selling it and buying a second hand 2015.

Needed keyboard repair twice in that time, and was horrible to type on. Useless touchbar, and an over-large trackpad that was constantly activating when typing. The last was odd as I regularly touch the old size trackpad with thumbs when typing but never had an issue. Add in the occasional freeze and crash and I feel it was a complete lemon.

I'm very happy with my 2015 and get longer battery times than I did with the newer model. I have no idea what I'll do when it needs replacing.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by skinnymuch on Thursday April 05, 2018 @03:45PM (#16768271)
Which monitor do you have?
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by BoorishBears on Thursday April 05, 2018 @05:12PM (#16768820)
Acer xr382cqk

IMO best all around monitor being produced today. 38” 1600p ultrawide (equivalent density to a 1440p 34” ultrawide), 75hz which is high enough for gaming without going into gamer aesthetic/retail markup territory, Freesync.

I can’t recommend it enough tbh

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by s73v3r_ on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:39PM (#16766458)
The Macbook Pro has 4 total USB C ports. You can use any of them to charge, and still use all 3 of the others for whatever else needs doing.

The keyboard is subjective.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by electricslpnsld on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:43PM (#16766504)
> The keyboard is subjective.

The feel of the keyboard is indeed subjective (I happen to like the feel of the keyboard on the new MacBook Pro), but in this case Apple genuinely built a buggy keyboard, so much so that people are writing songs about it [1].

[1] https://youtu.be/FdS3tjEIqUA

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by adanto6840 on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:59PM (#16766658)
I ordered one and then returned it (for the first time ever after ~10 or so MBPs) -- ended up just purchasing a new refurb non-touchbar MBP, which is what it was replacing too.

Largest reason for return: G key. 30% of the time = two Gs. 50% = 1 G. Remaining 20% = 0 Gs/no keydown whatsoever. Hah.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by matwood on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:43PM (#16766500)
> The keyboard is subjective.

Yeah, I think if the keyboard didn't break from a spec of dust it would be fine.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by avtar on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:43PM (#16766505)
The 13" Pro model has two USB-C ports.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by tibbon on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:02PM (#16766686)
My 13" Pro has four USB-C ports. I think it's just the non-touchbar one that only has two.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by saagarjha on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:11PM (#16766770)
Not all of them. The models with the Touch Bar have four.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by prepend on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:43PM (#16766498)
16gb ram isn’t very pro.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by ninkendo on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:47PM (#16766541)
Honestly I buy this argument way more than any complaints about the touch bar.

With my work my swap usage is 10-20GB at a time, between my IDE, app, tests, and browser tabs. 16GB is utterly painful but it’s the most you can buy.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by kevingadd on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:52PM (#16766581)
The CPU also isn't really up to par for pro use cases. I understand not putting a burly CPU and pile of RAM into the mid-high-tier laptop but developers and media people need something. Running parallel make on my brand new touch bar macbook is like 2-4x slower than doing it in a linux VM on my ~$1500 windows desktop from a year ago, to the point where I'd work more efficiently running remote desktop on a $200 chromebook.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by danieldk on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:33PM (#16766972)
Running parallel make on my brand new touch bar macbook is like 2-4x slower than doing it in a linux VM on my ~$1500 windows desktop from a year ago

It's also more than two times slower on my 2013 Dell Precision Xeon workstation.

But that comparison is not really fair, a MacBook Pro has to use a mobile CPU or it won't be able to dissipate the heat. Also, depending on ambient temperature, possible airflow, the MacBook's CPU probably throttles fairly early to prevent overheating.

A desktop CPU can larger power envelopes, typically throttles less and most virtualization has gotten so good that for CPU-bound workloads the difference between running on bare hardware or on a VM is barely noticeable.

to the point where I'd work more efficiently running remote desktop on a $200 chromebook.

Maybe it depends on the field I am working in, but I can't really run stuff on any laptop or desktop unless it is a > 5000 Euro workstation with plenty of RAM, storage, and a beefy GPU. The value that the Mac platform provides for me are the many applications that Chromebooks/Linux don't have good substitutes for, such as OmniGraffle, Deckset, Things, Microsoft Office, Little Snitch, Pixelmator, Acorn, Lightroom, and Affinity Designer. So, it's not just an expensive terminal ;).

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by prepend on Thursday April 05, 2018 @02:58PM (#16767914)
I have one because of iOS development. The touch bar is stupid but ignored. The touchid is actually pretty awesome and using it for sudo is pretty convenient, especially when in a group setting where I’m nervous about people noticing keystrokes (eg, Corp hackathons and stuff).

But the memory is noticeable. For general performance, but also for running lots of vms and stuff in different configurations.

Still situations where its convenient to spin stuff up locally rather than cloud.

Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by IOT_Apprentice on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:28AM (#16771329)
No. The MacBook Pro as implemented is a prosumer machine at best. A Pro machine would have higher end components at the BTO level. 1) larger size for greater battery capacity, 2) Xeon-D as an option, 3) 32-64 Gig of RAM, 4) High end graphics, 5) better keyboard. User replaceable drive, and memory. Apple has the capital to build a Halo laptop, just as they do for phones. They simply chose not to.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by slig on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:39PM (#16766464)
He probably wants a portable Mac that the user can upgrade RAM/SSD/battery with a non fluffy keyboard. Yeah, that ship has already sailed.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by schraeds on Thursday April 05, 2018 @02:59PM (#16767915)
Fluffy is about the worst adjective imaginable to describe Apple's butterfly keys. They are crisp and sharp, lacking in tactile response though.
Re:Apple’s 2019 Mac Pro will be shaped by workflows by slig on Friday April 06, 2018 @09:33AM (#16773061)
Agreed, I wasn't clear. I meant the touch bar.