News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by firasd on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:24PM (#16759836)
> What collateral damage is being done?

The damage is that if you're writing about cryptocurrency as a topic, the same way any media publication would (rather than trying to scam anyone or sell anything) you're still getting shut down.

Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by kneath on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:31PM (#16759889)
All of the examples in the article (zeitgeist-style newsletters) fall very clearly under a marketing umbrella by my judgement. They're the TV Guides of cryptocurrency. Maybe they don't (all) have affiliate links, but advertising is far beyond that line in 2018. If it's got the name of a specific currency in any of the emails, it's marketing.
Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by zodiac on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @08:28PM (#16760668)
> If it's got the name of a specific currency in any of the emails, it's marketing.

I think this is way too broad and leads to absurd conclusions. For instance there's an MIT research group whose mailing list I subscribe to (not mailchimp) and which would fall under marketing by your criteria. Papers with specific cryptocurrency names occasionally appear in top CS conferences.

Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by kneath on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:24PM (#16760966)
Yes, capitalism has infested every corner of our existence. Universities and conferences are massive distributors of marketing materials. They are both capitalistic enterprises.

It is very difficult to find non-marketing content in modern times. Especially in America.

Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by zodiac on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:07AM (#16764515)
Do you think literally every piece of research which studies for e.g. something about ethereum is marketing for ethereum? Would you use the same logic to conclude that a systems paper that implements some novel kernel architecture by patching linux and running experiments is "marketing for Linux"? That someone implementing a novel language feature in GHC is "marketing for Haskell"? That a paper evaluating QUIC using anonymous Chrome telemetry is "marketing for Chrome"?
Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by firasd on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:42PM (#16761070)
The whole business model of MailChimp is to get people to pay to send emails, so obviously they are not averse to marketing per se. The reason people are unhappy is that if I can send "MySQL news this week" updates to my hypothetical subscribers on MailChimp, why can't I send "Ethereum news this week"? Educational and informational materials are significantly different from "Buy my token!11"
Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by rspeer on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @11:00PM (#16761429)
If you're paying to send people "Ethereum news this week", it's because you have a financial interest in promoting certain things that happen on Ethereum. There are plenty of places you can discuss Ethereum without paying for it.
Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by rspeer on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @10:55PM (#16761398)
Fill me in here: if you're really not selling or promoting anything, what's the use case of MailChimp? MailChimp didn't make all other mailing lists and forums stop existing. It's just the service that's optimized for marketing, for the case where if someone doesn't see your e-mail, it's your loss and not theirs.

Like, if you want to have an erudite discussion of the technical and mathematical underpinnings of zk-SNARKs, there must be a substantial number of people in that discussion who are capable of setting up a Mailman server.

Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by firasd on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @11:26PM (#16761531)
The New York Times has newsletters. They are 'promoting' their content by sending you email updates, but that doesn't mean they are equivalent to ICO scammers.

Here's a response from MailChimp to a nonprofit educational org that suggests they are willing to make distinctions and not just class everyone who writes blockchain-related content as shady: https://twitter.com/MailChimp/status/981554164626010112

Re:MailChimp's Ban on Cryptocurrency Marketing Is Causing Co... by rspeer on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:16AM (#16761719)
I don't know why you'd think I'd be surprised that MailChimp has customers who use it for its purpose, which is marketing.

It seems you're saying that MailChimp should be entirely neutral and should let you promote anything you want, and they disagree. MailChimp does not want to allow cryptocurrency promotions. Cryptocurrency promotions have negative externalities. That's not collateral damage, it's the entire point of their decision.

Whether they are "equivalent to ICO scammers" doesn't enter into it.