News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by jumelles on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:18PM (#16759210)
> 80,945 against and 75 in favor

Life in a democracy?

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by koolba on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:29PM (#16759320)
From the article:

>> But despite deep public opposition, the agency concluded that the company's plan met with legal standards.

I’ll take equal interpretation of the law over mob rule any day of the week.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by gameswithgo on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:50PM (#16759530)
I notice a lot lately, maybe it has always been so, that some large powerful entity will insist that the citizen has been screwed over according to all proper procedures and applicable laws...
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Grovara123 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:33PM (#16759366)
Short and direct - well stated and agreed.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by banach on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:39PM (#16759428)
The holocaust was legal, slavery was legal, segregation was legal. If you use the state as a metric for ethics you'll end up disappointed.

-- @lex_looper

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:44PM (#16759476)
Are you seriously comparing pumping 1/2000 of the water that normally goes down the local river with the holocaust or slavery?
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by oarsinsync on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:03PM (#16759660)
It reads more like that you shouldn’t expect the state to behave ethically if there is no legal obligation to do so, and that what is considered ethical and/or legal can change over time.

Defending potentially bad behaviour solely on the basis that it’s legal behaviour may not be the best defence (outside of a court of law.)

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by cowpig on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:04PM (#16759667)
I don't think @banach did that.

The point of the quote was to point out that laws aren't necessarily right.

And this point you keep making about it only being a small % of the total water isn't very convincing. I'm sure you would mind if I embezzled 1/2000th of Michigan's GDP.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by brandonmenc on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:11PM (#16760901)
> laws aren't necessarily right

And neither is the public.

We once needed a law and show of force against public demonstrators to let black children into schools.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by sparrish on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:17PM (#16759781)
Embezzling is a poor comparison. This is Nestle getting legal permits to pull from a well.

A better comparison would be if you invoiced Michigan for 1/2000th of their GDP and the state and local governments paid it. In that case, I'm fine with it.

[dead]
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by domevent on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:13PM (#16759751)
This is arguing dishonestly, as you presumably understand the difference between using examples to illustrate a principle, and a direct comparison. Why not just address the point, instead of being “outraged” by his presentation?
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:28PM (#16760988)
> This is arguing dishonestly

No, it isn't.

He is arguing that the government of Michigan's laws are bad because the Nazis had bad laws.

There's dishonesty for you.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by portofcall on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @11:03PM (#16761450)
He is arguing that the government of Michigan's laws are bad because the Nazis had bad laws. There's dishonesty for you.

Yes, you’re being dishonest.

If you use the state as a metric for ethics you'll end up disappointed.

He spelled it out in the post you’re aggressively misinterpreting and it’s decidedly not the fiction you’re peddling. So are you really losing track of what’s been said, in which case it’s time to step back, or are you being dishonest? You don’t seem like you’re losing track, so...

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @11:16PM (#16761502)
I'm not "misinterpreting" anything, aggressively or otherwise. He is lumping all states together as "the state", giving an example of some unethical states, and arguing from that that no state is ethical, or pays any attention to ethical concerns.

That argument is pure garbage.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by portofcall on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @11:23PM (#16761527)
You said He is arguing that the government of Michigan's laws are bad because the Nazis had bad laws.

Which simply isn’t true. He actually said outright:

If you use the state as a metric for ethics you'll end up disappointed.

Now, you may think that’s garbage, but you’re not free to pretend that he said completely different things he didn’t actually say. Remember how you hate inaccuracy? Do you think that what you were doing before was accurate? How about playing semantic games now with the word “state,” is that accurate?

It isn’t, it’s evasive. So, what are you evading?

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Turing_Machine on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:35AM (#16764745)
There is no "the state" to "use as a metric". That's what's dishonest.

> Do you think that what you were doing before was accurate?

Pointing out that the government of Nazi Germany and the government of Michigan aren't the same in any meaningful way? Yes. That's accurate.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Normal_gaussian on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:04PM (#16759672)
They were accurately pointing out that conflating legal with ethical is not just incorrect but dangerous.

They were not comparing the activities.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:11PM (#16759724)
> They were accurately pointing out that conflating legal with ethical is not just incorrect but dangerous.

Equating the legal system of Michigan with the legal system of Nazi Germany is ludicrously incorrect.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by koolba on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @10:22PM (#16761272)
Segregation was mob rule. It took federal enforcement of anti discrimination laws to break it up.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by rch on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:26PM (#16759289)
> We don't have the power to say no arbitrarily. We can't just say no for reasons that aren't attached to the law.

Seems like the residents need to direct their energy towards lawmakers.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by slavik81 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:48PM (#16759509)
A government agency is similar to a court in that sense. It doesn't matter how many people want someone thrown in prison, the judge must have a reason based on existing law to do so.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Firerouge on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:23PM (#16759266)
It sounds like these comments were misdirected, and should have gone towards policy makers, not an agency that proclaims to only enforce existing policy.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:42PM (#16759460)
It turns out policy makers are not as responsive as they are supposed to be, so people are forced to seek other outlets to express their concern.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Spivak on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:31PM (#16759338)
At least to me, this is the system working.

Of course anything surrounding Michigan, Nestle and water is going to attract attention and serve as the backdrop for uninformed people to vent their anger. And despite all the backlash the adminstration followed the law and the right call was still made.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:41PM (#16759443)
That's nice for Nestle, but ignores the fact that Flint is still having water quality problems and replacement of the lead-tainted pipes won't be complete until 2020. It's entirely reasonable that citizens would like their government to prioritize their wellbeing at the expense of regular procedure, considering that the Flint water crisis was a product of government error to start with.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:51PM (#16759542)
This facility is over a hundred miles from Flint, and on a completely different watershed. In fact, the watershed drains into a completely different Great Lake (Lake Michigan rather than Lake Huron).
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by anigbrowl on Thursday April 05, 2018 @02:54AM (#16762475)
I thought I was clear that I consider it a political rather than a hydrological problem.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by maxerickson on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:53PM (#16760070)
Hydrologically they are the same lake.

The rivers drain into it quite far apart though.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by dexterdog on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:33PM (#16759361)
That has to be a skewed sample. You can't get that kind of lopsidedness if the question is "Can I have permission to murder you right now?"
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by mehrzad on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:21PM (#16759236)
We Americans like to claim we live in a republic and not a democracy, but we live in a broken republic too.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by tracker1 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:34PM (#16759379)
The problem is, at this point the "representation" is far too removed from the governed... Very few people "know" their representatives (local, state and federal alike). And the public image is very manipulated. Unfortunately, people no longer vote for who they feel is a better person, but who is in their party and has a better smile and message.

In the internet age, it's almost worse with the sheer amount of disinformation which cannot be contained or offset in both directions, for the better or the worse of a given candidate.

It's disillusioning and outright sad. That doesn't even account for external pressures and interests.

Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by topspin on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:41PM (#16759436)
Life where property rights exist.
Re:Michigan OKs Nestlé Water Extraction, Despite Public Comm... by Zeta_Function on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:21PM (#16759243)
You can call a clod a cake, right? We don’t live in a democracy, we live in an indirectly federated republic. I’m this case a very badly corrupt one, run by plutocrats for longer than any of us have been alive.

We have killer propaganda though.