The entire interface was identical, right down to the little people that depicted your sex, everything was identical, the layout, the images, the user interface, everything.
I will give them a grudging credit for being able to copy everything with more style, but I have to say as a user it was very confusing to see a game, pitched as a NEW game, that was identical in every respect to the competitor.
I have NEVER seen such blatant copying, and it was the same with many other games, they weren't "inspired by", they were image for image, ui for ui replicas.
I did play Farmville for a while, but they just don't know how to make these games compelling, and I lost interest.
I don't think that there is anything wrong with taking an idea and making it your own, but to take someone's work and copy it almost verbatim, that seems pretty low to me.
edit: I remembered that I have heard another version, with a different take: "In a street where there are several bakeries, next business that will open up will be a bakery" - I actually like that one more.
I always thought it was a clever way to avoid paying for market research by piggybacking on someone else's.
But, I highly suggest you listen to the whole episode (hour long).
Last time I was in downtown Seattle, Westlake Center (a small shopping mall) had three. Upstairs, downstairs, and a standalone building, all within a couple minutes' walk of each other.
It's probably for the best they've seen the need to close some stores, but I almost wish they weren't, just for the absurdity of it.
http://www.theonion.com/articles/new-starbucks-opens-in-rest...
Now, if you, the new kid on the block, enter this highly competitive market, you need to be extremely clever to be competing while not loosing money and, if so you manage to compete, they would probably copy you before they die themselves.
If however you decide to take a little bit more time upfront and invest more effort to find a place where your service is needed and there is little competition, you'll be making healthy profits. That is why copying does not win in the long term and even the company in question has now had to start to make their own products.
If there's a secret hidden market somewhere well the hard part isn't starting a business there, it's finding it!
Then you find that people go to "bakery street" instead as there's a choice. The 3 stores share the whole market and you get none.
I've often thought of all of the slow-moving entrenched companies that could just have everything taken out from under them by a good hungry team using modern tools and techniques. As long as you're not actively producing new legacy code, you should be able to catch up in terms of product sophistication pretty quickly.
That's not to say one could build FarmVille in a regular weekend, it would have to be a 3-day weekend.
But did Zynga initially improve upon Farm Town or simply attract more users through a multimillion pound ad budget? For the consumer market "copy what the cool kids are doing and market the hell out of it" is arguably an even more successful strategy than "take something proven and make it better"
The blatant art rip-off is evil, but the methodology of "taking something proven, and making it better" is not.
Apple does this all the time, and I don't fault them for it.
For the HN crowd who "can't find an idea for a startup", maybe this is a really good method of finding one. Look at what's successful out there, and emulate to make it better.