News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by vowelless on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @11:50AM (#16755857)
On one hand, I reluctantly appreciate Trump's election because it will force silicon valley to think many times before readily giving up user privacy to the US government. I felt like the attitude was very lax under Obama (despite the Snowden revelations).

On the other hand, this bothers me a bit because it continues to allow people in the valley to maintain a (sorry to use this word) delusion that what they are doing is "moral". If Google stops working with the Pentagon after this petition, people in the valley will pat their backs and enjoy how they are making the world a better place. They will not have any incentive to rethink the sale of user data to advertisers, creating highly addictive mentally harmful products, etc.

Overall, it's good that at least people in the valley are somewhat mindful of their actions and care about society (compared my current industry, finance). I hope they can be successful at a deeper level.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by IAmEveryone on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:25PM (#16756898)
> allow people in the valley to maintain a (sorry to use this word) delusion that what they are doing is "moral"

People refusing to work on military technology isn't "appearing moral". It's just "moral", at least if you consider war to be generally amoral.

People here and elsewhere have been throwing the term "virtue signalling" around a lot in the last year or so. This is a perfect counterexample: Google employees speaking out against military tech are shouldering the risk of appearing disloyal to their employer. If Google were to cut their military ties, they would forgo whatever benefit they previously sought in that relationship.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by adsgjlnionio on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @07:15PM (#16760234)
Do you think the US should stop developing military technology? I doubt it, and I doubt many Google employees do, either. I doubt they would be happy to live in a world where the U.S. has a weaker military than countries like China or Russia. I also doubt they would approve of throwing out our advanced targeting technology in favor of Vietnam-style carpet bombing.

They are uncomfortable with killing people even though a technologically-advanced military is probably a good thing. They are comfortable with tracking and manipulating millions of people even though it's definitely a bad thing. This is squeamishness, not morality.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by musage on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:16AM (#16761718)
What you say about "your country" kinda legitimates anyone saying that about "their" country, too. There's plenty of arms dealer selling to all sorts of sides, are there not? And generally speaking, at best soldiers defend against invading soldiers, at worst they are invading or "just" murdering some or a lot of civilians.

Remember when the cold war ended, for a while, but military budgets didn't exactly collapse? Isn't that "funny" how that works, and how we have no problem realizing that in other contexts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebound_effect_(conservation)

You make war profitable, you will have more war. The details are trickier, sure. Slogans aren't enough. But if you don't even have the will, don't worry about finding a way.

> I doubt they would be happy to live in a world where the U.S. has a weaker military than countries like China or Russia.

Yeah, nevermind the big nations all having their go at weaker nations, and the US wars of aggression, under exactly that pretense. No, it's really that the every last person in that huuuuuge industry -- shoveling tax dollars into gadgets that can be used to defend, to destroy, to enforce resource extraction as well as for domestic control -- wants to look out for you, because you have the same nationality in the passport. It's the children on non-Americans that get labels like "fun-sized terroris", American children have names. Those lines could not ever blur.

Yes, you can't just unilaterally disarm. But you also can't keep hitting others (and yourself) while gearing up even more, at increasing rate, while subverting self-determination of others and intellectual honesty of self at every corner, and then say "it just happens to be a dangerous world, I'm just reacting". The people you're just reacting to say the same thing, and the people who sell you and them that lie laugh all the way to the bank, and should there be need for it, they won't share their bunker with you. They'd sooner share it with Russian and Chinese war profiteers, so to speak.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by teen on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @07:38PM (#16760363)
.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by sureaboutthis on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @07:59PM (#16760499)
If that would ever happen, we wouldn't be talking about this at all. Reality check!
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by opportune on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:50PM (#16757706)
Right, it's reminiscent of decrying "virtue signaling" as if there is anything bad with doing something because it's virtuous

We shouldn't make fun of people because they "do the right thing". That sounds like something Facebook would do

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by nickpinkston on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @03:32PM (#16758122)
The problem is when you write off your culpability to do more because "At least I did something" via virtue signaling.

So no, it's not wrong to virtue signal necessarily, but often is seen as an empty gesture by people who don't talk/act towards the actual problems.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by IAmEveryone on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @03:46PM (#16758284)
It's an intellectually dishonest argument, because it actually uses someone's profession of good intentions, accepts them, and then somehow turns it against the speaker.

As used on the internet, it's also useless because it always assumes the speaker doesn't actually act on their believes, and there usually is no way for them to prove their willingness to act on their believes.

It also ignores that even just stating such believes can have an effect. After all, these statements are used to convince others to adopt them.

The best proof of the last point may actually be this protest by Google employees: their conviction was probably formed by reading and hearing about the ethical responsibility of engineers, a topic that is certainly teeming with "virtue signalling" according to the common definition. They might even be the product of Google's own "virtue signalling", i. e. "Do no Evil". Maybe Larry Page and Sergey Brin only ever wanted to pay lip service to ethical behaviour. But their employees didn't get the full memo, took them by their word, and are now acting upon it.

In this sense, "virtue signalling" aka "Greenwashing" or "diversity boilerplate" may start as a cynical profit-motivated lie, and end up changing the world for the better.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by jpttsn on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:27PM (#16759860)
Reliable signals are as a rule expensive.

In decrying “virtue signaling”, I think critics express “talk is cheap” not just “talk can be false.”

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by AndyNemmity on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @07:03PM (#16760149)
Saying "talk is cheap" implores the listener to act on their statements.

Saying "virtue signaling" implores the listeners to stop expressing their views.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by olleromam91 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:29PM (#16760997)
Potato potato
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by nickpinkston on Thursday April 05, 2018 @11:02AM (#16765519)
Yea, I don't think virtue signaling is always wrong, but I think there is wrong virtue signaling.

A lot of the vitriol on the internet is destructive virtue signaling using holier than thou approaches that alienate people close to your position, this causes division, not unity, and is one of the key issues on the Left - i.e. the Left attacking itself over minutiae as the Right marches on.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by opportune on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @03:47PM (#16758295)
Sure, and I agree that Google shouldn't stop here. But then again there is a difference, at least in my opinion, between doing something that helps the military in a support role and doing something that actively assists them in killing people. Letting the military use google cloud or google search is different than working on an AI-assisted targeting system for drones. That is where I would draw the line for myself.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by pathseeker on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:07PM (#16760885)
>It's just "moral", at least if you consider war to be generally amoral.

The military is also responsible for defense and disaster recovery (national guard). There are many technologies created to be resilient and life-saving by the military (ARPANET). Working with on certain military-funded projects is definitely non black-and-white like you imply.

[dead]
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by wilsonnb on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @04:14PM (#16758572)
There are plenty of jobs that are more immoral than working for Google. You don't even have to look outside of the tech field.

I'm sure someone is making a lot of money helping distribute child pornography over the internet. Plenty of tech jobs in human trafficking, too, I would imagine.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by airstrike on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @12:12PM (#16756111)
Being “mindful of their actions” doesn’t necessarily mean they are doing the right thing. The road to hell is paved with good intentions.

I don’t really get why anyone would want drones to be less accurate, but maybe that just means I’m just a no-good warmongering fool, right?

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by vowelless on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:52PM (#16757157)
Incidentedly, I worked on drones for the Navy and Marines for many years.

My issue is with the hypocracy. Don't claim to be moral and sell this Kool aid. It sounds a lot like religious high priests that I have a viceral reaction to (given where I come from). It could just be my own personal issue with the faux moral sell of the valley.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by jacquesm on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:23PM (#16757466)
> My issue is with the hypocrisy.

There are degrees of morality.

Just like a criminal might object to being defrauded because they feel it crosses a line.

Everybody is a hypocrite to some extent, you at least seem to be aware of that fact that you are simply a gun for hire which makes it easier to reason about the position of others.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by vowelless on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:39PM (#16757618)
> you at least seem to be aware of that fact that you are simply a gun for hire which makes it easier to reason about the position of others.

That probably is the case. Morality is also very subjective (which, to some, is a matter of belief). Maybe "hypocrisy" is not the right word. Perhaps I was looking for "lack of self awareness". That is kind of what I meant with "delusion".

There are a lot of good, empathetic people in Silicon Valley. More empathetic than probably any other subgroup I have ever encountered. And they have a deep desire to change the world. I have a lot of respect for that.

But they also circle jerk about that all the time (you see this in finance at charity events too). And in that circle jerk, thinking they are improving humanity, they end up cozing up with the federal government, foreign dictators, and even suppressing free thought! And I am not acquitting the Military Industrial Complex of doing a lot of the same things (but at least they are less deluded, having the "American interests" narrative as opposed to "make the world a better place" narrative).

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by jacquesm on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:52PM (#16757726)
To some extent living in a self-reinforcing bubble will cause people to believe their own bullshit. SV is not unique in this, there are plenty of people who are obviously busy with enriching themselves and their buddies while doing this 'to improve the world'. I don't buy it, and I would prefer it if they were honest about it but then again what does it matter, they're certainly not fooling anybody.

The few that really want to improve the world stand out and don't feel the need to sell themselves as improving the world, they don't need to: it's obvious, their actions speak louder than words.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by smokeyj on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @12:43PM (#16756466)
> but maybe that just means I’m just a no-good warmongering fool, right?

More specifically, a warmongering fool who can't discern a false dichotomy - because your options in life are rarely ever drones vs more lethal drones.

These regions we're using drones in. They could probably use more tools to enable true democratic representation. Isn't that what Google should be doing, given that they "don't do evil"? Building tools to blow people up seems slightly counter intuitive.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by plandis on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:10PM (#16756741)
Id argue it's not a false dichotomy because drone strikes will go on regardless of what Google does. It's very clear that whatever collateral damage drones currently cause is an acceptable cost to the militaries using them.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by smokeyj on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:29PM (#16756932)
"If you don't help make drones more accurate, you're the reason for collateralized murder".

Or, you could like, just stop droning innocent people to death. Not saying we all have to agree, but just that factually speaking - it's within the realm of possibilities. And for that reason it's a false dichotomy.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by plandis on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @03:08PM (#16757880)
> "If you don't help make drones more accurate, you're the reason for collateralized murder".

I never stated anything about blame, nor do I think that choosing to not participate makes someone culpable.

> Or, you could like, just stop droning innocent people to death.

I have not "droned" anyone.

> Not saying we all have to agree, but just that factually speaking - it's within the realm of possibilities.

It's possible, sure, but certainly not probable. Drone strikes are increasing, not decreasing. I don't think you're thinking about this very pragmatically.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by airstrike on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:42PM (#16757059)
You’re saying that as if droning was specifically meant to target innocent people, when that’s exactly what they’re trying to avoid.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by staplers on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:55PM (#16757201)

  that’s exactly what they’re trying to avoid.

   The road to hell is paved with good intentions.
Circular argumentation
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by Nimitz14 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @04:03PM (#16758463)
No. It's not. Learn logic.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by jstanley on Thursday April 05, 2018 @12:30AM (#16761780)
But how many of the "non-innocent" people who have been killed in drone strikes had actually been found guilty in a fair trial?

And of those who had been, how many were sentenced to death?

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by airstrike on Thursday April 05, 2018 @10:15PM (#16770423)
It’s war, not a court. Society hasn’t legislated that those who attack this country should be presumed innocent and convicted only after due process. This is true in any country.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by kachurovskiy on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:24PM (#16756896)
"go on regardless" argument can be used to justify absolutely anything so I don't think it helps advancing the meaningful debate.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by olleromam91 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:33PM (#16761020)
Sure it can. We can ask "what are you going to do now that we agree it happens regardless?".

If you can accept existence contains horror in all forms, then you can go on your way to make the best impact you can for those you care about.

If you can't accept that, you just sit around arguing if life could be perfect.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by kiliantics on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @04:12PM (#16758550)
> regardless of what Google does

If Google employees wanted to, they could probably put a lot of pressure on the military directly. Imagine Google no longer served ip addresses that belonged to the military unless they ended their drone strikes. Or say they turned off google maps for anyone that is known to work for the military.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by chatmasta on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:01PM (#16757256)
Didn’t they eliminate that don’t be evil slogan a few years ago?
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by minkzilla on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @10:19PM (#16761258)
Now they can be evil guilt free!
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by cwkoss on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:08PM (#16757331)
Hell, our own country could probably use more tools to enable true democratic representation.
Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by untog on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @11:57AM (#16755952)
> On the other hand, this bothers me a bit because it continues to allow people in the valley to maintain a (sorry to use this word) delusion that what they are doing is "moral"

> They will not have any incentive to rethink the sale of user data to advertisers

Is it not possible that one will lead to the other? We're seeing the beginnings of a real examination of the power Silicon Valley giants have. Recent revelations about Facebook, amongst others, shows that awareness of advertising profiles etc. is increasing as well.

Re:Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. P... by mc32 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @05:27PM (#16759303)
Not only that, but unless the effort is global, the impact of any AI will deliver greater effect in countries with less citizen rights.

So while it's great these protestors want to protect us from AI, those in China, Russia, India, Iran, will endure a greater threat from AI and it behooves us to be at the forefront lest we fall behind.

In other words a moratorium can only work if all participants agree and participate. Sort of like the anti nuclear proliferation treaty.