Short answer: your idea probably won't last long.
Will you turn over your leadership to the machines? Humans are so bad at it.
Translates to: Will you turn over your leadership to the humans running the machines?
I like the theory of a perfectly impartial AI dictator. However, I don't believe such a thing is possible since it must be programmed by people and carries any biases (deliberate or accidental) those people program into it.
Read Hobbes' Leviathan, it discusses this. A prerequisite for success the sovereign must establish a state religion, subjects comply or are executed.
And then John Locke, with emphasis on consent of the governed.
And why not the Catholic Church? The pope is essentially what you describe but they have been many bad Popes. Nevertheless as an institution it endures, with and without justice.
A sovereign who is completely selfless would not be a human. So you're necessarily searching for deities or an off worlder. And when they're done? Who then? Sounds chaotic and capricious.
All human beings have survival instincts. But we manages to build soldiers that are willing to risk their lives for random stuff. Right?
In such way, it might be possible to build, or grow, generations of such people, completely selfless..
I mean orders from higher authorities. Are the soldiers given reason or entitled for one? They are just supposed to obey, right?
"They suffered and they did their duty so a sheltered homeland can enjoy the peace that was purchased at such a high cost." Eugene Sledge
Are you seriously saying all the troops deployed in Nam and the middle east was protecting US constitution..
That said, according to the UCMJ, the orders given to slaughter civilians in Vietnam were unlawful and a soldier refusing to obey them would not have been prosecuted.
"Obedience to orders. It is a defense to any offense that the accused was acting pursuant to orders unless the accused knew the orders to be unlawful or a person of ordinary sense and understanding would have known the orders to be unlawful."
http://jsc.defense.gov/Portals/99/Documents/MCM2016.pdf?ver=...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Thompson_Jr.
https://web.archive.org/web/20120324030925/http://www.usna.e...
But when they ordered to go to a different country and fight a war over there. that is not what they originally signed up for, right? So they are putting their lives on line for the whims of someone in administration, and not for a cause they care about.
That is all I am saying.
So, my original argument is that, If we are able to make human beings to risk their lives for causes so disconnected from themselves, Why can't we have human beings that are ready to lead an enforced, selfless life devoid of normal human joys and full fillments in the service of their country?
Your end statement describes brainwashing, which has been proven not to work. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/TiG8cLkBRW4QgsfrR/notes-on-b...
Even if the cause might be a good one, we still value our individuality over mass enforced and indoctrinated conformism. It might be anything but harmonic, and quite chaotic, but individuality gives us a diversity of ideas and views, thus enabling adaptability, which is one of homo sapiens sapiens biggest advantages.
I'll always take a corrupt politician over a benevolent dictator.
Please provide some support for that deeply subjective statement.
https://aeon.co/essays/the-merits-of-taking-an-anti-anti-com...
Most horrible? It doesn't seem unreasonable to use body count of a country's own citizens as a proxy for "horror".
Did you read the article?
I've found it a very common tendency to lump everything free market capitalists don't like as "communism bad!" and "socialism bad!", which I guess stems from decades and decades of cultural indoctrination, fueled by the military industrial complex.
For instance, an anarcho-communist is very far from whatever haphazard centrally planned mess was in place in the USSR at any given time.
Oh, the old "no real scotsman" argument. See, the whole communist ideology is like convincing people to jump of a cliff so they can fly: when they inevitably fall to their death, you just tell that since they didn't fly, it wasn't what you envisioned.
Dictatorship and blood is the inevitable outcome of Marx's ideas executed on scale of millions. As inevitable as gravity.
Did you read the article?
https://aeon.co/essays/the-merits-of-taking-an-anti-anti-com...
Marxism and what happened in countries like USSR, China and Cambodia only have an extremely tenuous connection, most of it related to the propaganda fed to the populace to force the tyrannical regime on them, without too much opposition.
Dude, I live and Moscow. My whole family survived 70 years of communism. I seen first hand how capitalism and free markets raised us from hunger and poverty to first world country living standards.
Please, don't make assumptions about people on the internet, you may end up completely wrong.
If you think the majority of people in Russia enjoy a first world standard of living, you're sorely mistaken. Moscow is very much an outlier.
Compared to Soviet Union, modern Russia is light years ahead. Of course, all this progress is built on the foundation laid down in the 90s, and is slowly deteriorating away for the last 10 years.
Am I wrong in saying that if you have enough resources, corrupt politicians and authorities will let you dictate the affairs under them?
So a dictator, as you say exerciser their power to enforce their own agenda. While a corrupt politician sells them off to the highest bidder, to enforce what ever agenda they have...
The only thing better in that scenario is that the "highest bidder" may have an incentive to not kill droves of people, since they probably have a business to run, and that often require people..Also, business does not really have an ideology or a philosophy. It just need to grow its profits..
> But an idealist who holds their ideal or political theory with the force of a religion is far worse, because they commit their horrors in the name of doing good, and so their benevolent impulses seem to them to be temptations - something to be resisted in order to do what is "good".
We are talking about a benevolent dictator here. If you are saying that they ll resist their benevolent impulses, how are they a benevolent dictator in the first place?
[Edit: reworded for clarity.]
So I think there is always an Idea of the subset of people you are meant to serve, and their well being being your highest priority. In your example, the "proletariat" were that subset, so it is only their duty to protect them from oppression.
If that is so, how they are benevolent in the first place, or "wanting to do good" as you say?
And as we see, even in the USA as we speak it’s easy to take some rights from the people without too much fuss (just enough distraction).
Would it be possible to appoint a dictator, who has no other incentive other then serve the people. For ex, they ll sever every human relation, cannot own property, will have zero privacy, cannot reproduce and have children etc. But they ll be held to the highest honor and their every needs taken care of...
In short, something like the life of a religious saint or a nun.