News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:16AM (#1675227)
So, how about all those people that were supporting apples' right to run their app store the way they see fit and who said that there is no point complaining about it?

I think this proves that complaining about stuff like this is well worth the effort, assuming that that - and not some backroom pressure - is what caused them to back off. They mention it in their release so I figure it must have been a major factor.

edit:

the plaintext version of the appstore guidelines:

http://ww.com/appstore.html

I've been reading through the guidelines while fixing the markup and it seems to me that it's very reasonable the way it is worded and those terms that are left.

I'd feel pretty good developing under these terms.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by lurch_mojoff on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:23AM (#1675249)
The thing is most of the complaining about this was not the constructive "hey, Apple have you considered so-and-so", but rather the whiny "waaaa... Apple are Nazis" kind.

And as you point out there is no evidence that it is the complaining that made Apple reconsider. It could very well be something entirely different, e.g. the FTC probe.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:25AM (#1675256)
Plenty of it was very constructive, it pointed out why the choice of tools should be left to the developer and how not relaxing this restriction would make it easier for people to develop for android than for the Iphone.

If the FTC probe (or the rise of android) has anything to do with it then I doubt we'll ever know, but I'm all for taking this on face value and believing them when they publicly admit to listening to their devs. It's a nice thing to be able to hold them to at a future date.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by GavinB on Thursday September 09, 2010 @10:20AM (#1675468)
The FTC probe may well have been prompted by all of the complaining. They don't exist in a vacuum, even if it sometimes seems that way.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @10:32AM (#1675513)
It's hard to resist the temptation to follow that line of thinking, but given a complete absence of evidence and a very public acknowledgement that they listened to their developers I think that's the prudent option for now.

It certainly looks like they are sincere about it, and if they are not this will hollow out their position in the future quite a bit and they did not have to give any reason at all.

Listening to your developers is not such a bad thing, after all.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by lurch_mojoff on Thursday September 09, 2010 @10:03AM (#1675391)
Well, it looked plenty for very small values of plenty, from where I stand. There were some very well reasoned arguments against the restriction - arguments like the fact that many libraries and game engines require the flexibility that scripting allows; or like the fact that there are languages and environments that are more conducive of tackling certain types of problems. Those, however were drowned in a sea of petty complaints like "I know language XYZ and now Apple are making me learn their sucky ObjC" or "Apple just want to prevent you from porting your app to a competing platform, them Nazis", or dramatic pronouncements that Apple have turned their back on the hacker crowd and thus are stifling innovation.

And I'm not saying we shouldn't believe Apple when they say they've listened to the developer community. I am saying that such decisions usually factor in a broader spectrum of reasons. At the very least, there are may examples of Apple not budging on issues, regardless of the huge ruckus.

I'm also not saying we shouldn't complain. I am saying we should cut on the drama, try to understand Apple's rationale for their decisions, and figure out a way to meet them midway. Or as Apple say in the intro to the App Store Review Guidelines - "If it sounds like we're control freaks, well, maybe it's because we're so committed to our users and making sure they have a quality experience with our products. Just like almost all of you are too."

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @10:09AM (#1675421)
> "I know language XYZ and now Apple are making me learn their sucky ObjC"

That's a very valid complaint imo, except for the 'sucky', was that present in the original?

> "Apple just want to prevent you from porting your app to a competing platform, them Nazis"

Are you sure about the 'them Nazis' bit in this one ? Otherwise, again, that's a valid complaint.

> I'm also not saying we shouldn't complain. I am saying we should cut on the drama,

Indeed.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by chc on Thursday September 09, 2010 @02:30PM (#1676333)
"Sucky" isn't very descriptive, but I wouldn't blame somebody used to a more advanced or coherent language for feeling frustrated with Objective-C. It is a backwards language in many ways, and I say that as somebody who's been writing it for the better part of a decade.

It doesn't even have namespaces — something that has been standard in every language since the '90s. Instead, you must stick a two- or three-character prefix on all your class and function names (some people even recommend prefixing method names) and hope that nobody else happened to pick the same two or three characters for theirs.

For another example, it has a strongly dynamic OO model, but a singularly unhelpful static type system that is shackled with C compatibility, leaving the language in this awkward limbo between static and dynamic, where you're offered all these tantalizing paths that turn out to be blocked by walls.

Yet another: It has monkey-patching like Ruby, but it lacks the language or library support to do it anywhere near as cleanly (which is saying something if you know how messy Ruby monkey patches can be), to the point where some parts are almost necessary and others are almost unusable and it's not obvious at first where the pitfalls lie.

(On the other hand, a lot of people hate Objective-C for pretty bad reasons too. There seems to be a legion of PHP converts who really want to write PHP in Objective-C.)

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by tjr on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:00PM (#1676461)
I've been doing a lot of Objective-C coding the past few months, and have found it surprisingly pleasant, once I got used to the syntax. Maybe I had low usability expectations for a language based on C. :-)
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by chc on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:22PM (#1676543)
It's not unusable, and overall I actually prefer it to, say, C or Java. But compared to modern languages it has some glaring weaknesses.

Also, you have to be careful to distinguish between the framework and the language. Cocoa is an excellent framework that does a great job playing to Objective-C's strengths. It's the language that I'm criticizing here.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by sprout on Thursday September 09, 2010 @12:24PM (#1675869)
>That's a very valid complaint imo, except for the 'sucky', was that present in the original?

While 'sucky' isn't up to HN's style standards, and a more reasoned response is always preferable, I personally don't think the prohibition Apple put in place was sufficiently reasonable to merit a reasonable response.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jrockway on Thursday September 09, 2010 @10:06AM (#1675402)
Those, however were drowned in a sea of petty complaints like "I know language XYZ and now Apple are making me learn their sucky ObjC" or "Apple just want to prevent you from porting your app to a competing platform, them Nazis"

Uh, what? These seem like perfectly legitimate complaints to me. Why shouldn't you be allowed to use the tools you already know how to use? Why shouldn't you be allowed to write once and run anywhere?

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by maxjg on Thursday September 09, 2010 @10:34AM (#1675520)
I've got nothing against your point on using the tools you know, but I can at least see where Apple is coming from with disallowing write once, run everywhere, especially regarding UI (think Java apps on OS X).
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by Symmetry on Thursday September 09, 2010 @01:14PM (#1676059)
But doesn't Apple already have user interface guidelines to let them reject apps that (inappropriately) behave the same way on different platforms?
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by mquander on Thursday September 09, 2010 @10:00AM (#1675384)
What kind of constructive arguments, exactly, need to be marshaled against it? "Hey, Apple, have you considered that a blanket ban on third-party development tools fucks over developers who use third-party tools?" Why, yes, I suspect that they did consider that.

It's not like there is some equal subtle list of pros and cons that need to be weighed, here.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by brlewis on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:49AM (#1675342)
I think you mean "as you point out there is no proof...". He points out that there is evidence in his "They mention it in their release" sentence.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by mkramlich on Friday September 10, 2010 @03:22AM (#1678163)
Complaining is always useful. It conveys information.

It's even better if you convey a suggestion on how specifically to improve things. But often the complaint itself contains that, implied.

For example, a what-you-would-call whiny complaint of "waaaaa... don't touch my arm with that torch, it burns!" contains the rather useful suggestion (implied) to stop touching my arm with that torch. To be more relevant, if Apple suddenly says you can't use any language but XYZ, and we go "waaaa...." what we are saying is "let us use XYZ". I hope that is obvious and implicit in all such cases. :)

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by ams6110 on Thursday September 09, 2010 @08:29PM (#1677461)
My guess is that Apple thought they saw a problem on the horizon, threw out some very restrictive language to be sure they had as many known AND UNKNOWN bases covered, then after some more thoughtful consideration decided that they didn't need to be so strict after all, and relaxed the terms. This sort of pattern happens a lot: go overboard at first, then pull back as you get more comfortable with things.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by nanairo on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:39AM (#1675300)
Well, personally I think there is a difference.

I completely agree that it's always good for a customer to complain about the product if there are problems. Gosh: read all the Mac faithful complains when a new MacOS comes out! Similarly if your phone doesn't work, or your car is not comfortable you go and complain.

BUT, the crucial word there is customer. People who would never buy an Apple product out of principle, or unless Apple becomes totally completely open source/open market/whatever, then those complains are pointless.

It all goes back to "vote with your wallet". Apple may listen to the first ones because their behaviour may change: the latter won't, they'll just complain, and Apple couldn't care less.

That said Apple is also a pretty stubborn company, and often even when it is in their best interest and their customers are complaining (AND voting with their wallet) they may keep their believes. It's one of their problems, though it's of course their right, and it may even make sense.

(for example a luxury brand is more interested in maintaining their recognisable features rather than adapt... but it's their choice: they judge how many customers they lose in the short run vs. how many customers they will retain in the long run)

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:45AM (#1675323)
The argument has been made that for every iphone developer that would quit making apps another (or two) would take their place. And that may be true. But a developer that has quit is not going to sit around and do nothing.

He's going to use his expertise gained on the one platform to make a go of it on the other. So an exodus of frustrated developers is really a very big problem.

Of course the customers will never know of anything like that happening behind the scenes. But they'll see their buddies with their shiny non-apple phones do stuff that they'd like to be able to do.

Where developers go, customers follow, you ignore them at your peril.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by nanairo on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:52AM (#1675354)
At the same time developers follow customers. ;) It goes both ways.

But yeah, I agree with you. Do it at your peril, and they tried, kept going probably thinking the pros. out-weighted the cons, and eventually after 2 years pushing it, they relented.

That's all I am saying. And yes, I admit Apple would have sticked to its guns for a little bit longer (basically until, like in today's mac, users were so familiar with the mac UI, that any rougue developer would change it at his peril ;) ).

But anyway, customers feedback or developers feedback (as you point out) is very very different from the trolls and haters you see populating internet forums. :)

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by gcheong on Thursday September 09, 2010 @11:01AM (#1675596)
Periodically Apple sends a survey out to iPhone developers asking for feedback on various aspects of the developer program and App Store. This latest move by Apple gives me some hope that they aren't just round-filing the feedback.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jf on Thursday September 09, 2010 @06:25PM (#1677170)
As someone who works for a large software company. I can assure you that feedback from developers is not only hard to obtain, but highly valued and used to shape future decisions.

From my personal experience, people "in the trenches" use feedback from their constituents to add weight to their messages to their superiors.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jlongster on Thursday September 09, 2010 @11:22AM (#1675658)
Not sure about statement 2.9: "Apps that are "beta", "demo", "trial", or "test" versions will be rejected"

Does this mean no "lite" versions of games? That would affect tons of apps... unless Apple is about to come out with a way to bundle a lite version with your app.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2010 @11:24AM (#1675667)
That's a tricky one, you're right about that. Maybe there is a way to get some clarification on that one without having to go through a whole round of developing an app and then having it rejected or accepted. I think what they mean to say is that it should be a 'finished product' (no beta, no test), it should be fully functional (no demo or trial), so self contained.

If there is a more fully featured version of the game available for another platform I can't really see how that could lead to trouble, but it may be worth a bit of investigation beforehand.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by jlongster on Thursday September 09, 2010 @11:28AM (#1675675)
Yeah, I think you're right. If they had omitted "trial" I think it would be pretty clear, but that's a tricky word (trial can be the same as lite).
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by weaksauce on Thursday September 09, 2010 @12:37PM (#1675932)
I think trial software has the connotation of being time limited. This whole section of the rules is just saying that they should be able to use the software as much as they want without having a "dead" app in the phone after the software expires. Lite just means less features/levels so that is permissible.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by chc on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:12PM (#1676505)
Time-limited or nagware. Upsells are OK, but IIRC Apple doesn't like nags.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by SoftwareMaven on Thursday September 09, 2010 @04:48PM (#1676892)
They also don't like software that looks like some feature should work, but just pops up a "buy me" dialog. Lites are OK as long as they are internally consistant.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by Someone on Thursday September 09, 2010 @11:51AM (#1675763)
I haven't read the document, but in my mind, trial
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by benbeltran on Thursday September 09, 2010 @04:15PM (#1676759)
I think this may be because of in-app purchases. So you can distribute a free "full but locked" app, and then just add functionality with in-app purchases. Maybe they're trying to promote that?
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by kd5bjo on Thursday September 09, 2010 @12:09PM (#1675831)
There are a lot of items worded like this:

> Apps that do not use the MediaPlayer framework to access media in the Music Library will be rejected

That sounds like apps that don't access the Music Library at all will be rejected.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by mattparcher on Thursday September 09, 2010 @01:37PM (#1676148)
Good point. Perhaps instead:

Apps that access media in the Music Library, without using the MediaPlayer framework to do so, will be rejected.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by weaksauce on Thursday September 09, 2010 @12:32PM (#1675908)
Not really, you can bundle music in your app and call it however you like. If you are playing music from the music that you loaded from itunes then yes they want you to use that framework.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by chc on Thursday September 09, 2010 @02:38PM (#1676365)
It's kind of informally worded, as opposed to the precise legalese you tend to find in TOS documents. I think most people will understand the meaning.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by blasdel on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:12PM (#1676504)
Currently any app can just get raw read access to the Media Library SQLite database file — the current MediaPlayer framework just implements an unprivileged API on top of that.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by Lukeas14 on Thursday September 09, 2010 @02:54PM (#1676434)
My guess would be that it had more to do with the number of apps submitted since the policy was enacted than the number of complaints on internet forums.

I also believe the original policy had less to do with security and more to do with selling more MBPs (their higher margin product). So if their research showed that those mobile developers without a Mac chose to develop for other platforms instead of buying a Mac it would've only made sense to reverse their policy.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by andreyf on Thursday September 09, 2010 @10:36PM (#1677691)
I think this proves that complaining about stuff like this is well worth the effort, assuming that that - and not some backroom pressure - is what caused them to back off. They mention it in their release so I figure it must have been a major factor.

Their mentioning it is nothing but a PR excuse. This had nothing to do with you or me and everything to do with Adobe's lawyers.

Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by Estragon on Friday September 10, 2010 @05:52AM (#1678361)

  So, how about all those people... who said that there is no
  point complaining about it?
I don't think I was one of those people, but I don't think the complaints have had much practical effect, here. The real impetus is more likely that they are feeling the heat from the Android platform.
Re:Apple Relaxes iOS Restrictions On Development Tools, Publ... by GrandMasterBirt on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:29PM (#1677565)
Complaining does not work. Competition does. Apple finally has some so they are making developers happy before they all leave for android. Android is getting damn well polished.