Re:Suspect in YouTube Shooting Posted Rants About the Compan...
by komali2 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @12:33AM
(#16751945)
You made me scroll through the youtube TOS to see if that was considered a violation.
As far as I can tell it's technically not... in fact, I can't even find a blanket "YouTube reserves the right to remove any content, for any reason, whatsoever" statement. They don't actually need to state that in the TOS, because they do have that right, but, still.
Re:Suspect in YouTube Shooting Posted Rants About the Compan...
by declan on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:02AM
(#16752100)
Section 4(J):
"YouTube reserves the right to discontinue any aspect of the Service at any time."
Section 6(F): "YouTube reserves the right to remove Content without prior notice."
Re:Suspect in YouTube Shooting Posted Rants About the Compan...
by dvfjsdhgfv on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @03:13AM
(#16752670)
That's indeed quite telling about the TOS nowadays: two people from HN double/triple checked the TOS to find a simple statement and couldn't find it. Yet, it's there.
Re:Suspect in YouTube Shooting Posted Rants About the Compan...
by subcosmos on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @03:49AM
(#16752847)
We need a grep that finds semantic meaning instead of exact string matches. Like an latent factor model of sorts.
Re:Suspect in YouTube Shooting Posted Rants About the Compan...
by komali2 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @10:52AM
(#16755256)
I saw those, but the first is couched within the copyright violation rule, so I assumed it was associated. I.e. we can remove it for copyright violation at anytime.
For the second, I assumed that "if your content was removed for a reason we justified here, we don't have to warn you beforehand."
I'm no lawyer though and I'm sure in court those clauses would be summarily smacked across my face one way or the other.
Re:Suspect in YouTube Shooting Posted Rants About the Compan...
by Shank on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @12:48AM
(#16752027)
You made me scroll through the TOS again and triple check. Indeed, there is no clause for wholesale termination, but they do require you to follow the community guidelines. Those guidelines do say that you can't promote violence -- and while committing an act of violence isn't necessarily promotion, it could be interpreted as such.
Still interesting to see that there's no blanket termination policy, though. I stand thoroughly corrected.
To be fair, YouTube/Google just had an active shooter on their campus. If there's anything that justifies terminating someone's account, it would be opening fire on the company directly and injuring people.