Re:Uber disabled Volvo SUV's safety system before fatality
by kelnos on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:02PM
(#16750652)
Having a dumber system underneath the smarter system is a great idea. I'm not arguing against that. I'm arguing against having two separate systems that are unrelated and are built (likely) without a deep understanding of how the other behaves.
Uber themselves should have a dumber system built underneath the smarter system (and maybe they do!); that way they understand all the variables that govern the operation of both and can be reasonably sure that the two systems won't fight each other. They can also build an interlock that causes the smarter system to completely disengage if the dumber system has to take over. I of course don't know this for a fact, but I wouldn't be surprised if Uber doesn't and can't have a complete understanding of how the Volvo system works. Disabling it makes sense. Again, they should replace it with their own dumber system, but that's a separate issue.
Uber themselves should have a dumber system built underneath the smarter system (and maybe they do!); that way they understand all the variables that govern the operation of both and can be reasonably sure that the two systems won't fight each other. They can also build an interlock that causes the smarter system to completely disengage if the dumber system has to take over. I of course don't know this for a fact, but I wouldn't be surprised if Uber doesn't and can't have a complete understanding of how the Volvo system works. Disabling it makes sense. Again, they should replace it with their own dumber system, but that's a separate issue.